I recall pushing Wayde Mills on Demonland for us and I was wrong. He has just been delisted by Lions.

I recall pushing Wayde Mills on Demonland for us and I was wrong. He has just been delisted by Lions.

Is he a well-built CHB, who played a few games in his 1st season? If that's him, I thought he looked pretty promising as well.

Is he a well-built CHB, who played a few games in his 1st season? If that's him, I thought he looked pretty promising as well.

Yes 196cms and a good hard kid who has done it fairly tough. I don't know if he could play forward but he is big and strong. It sounds like either disposal or pace could be the problem. Others may know more about his recent form in the QAFL.

disposals were his downfall. he couldn't hit the backside of a barn

disposals were his downfall. he couldn't hit the backside of a barn

Yes, his disposals were terrible. His kicking style was awkward and ineffective.

He has no future in the AFL, so lets not have anyone saying we should snap him up in the PSD.

Yes, his disposals were terrible. His kicking style was awkward and ineffective.

He has no future in the AFL, so lets not have anyone saying we should snap him up in the PSD.

Agreed.

It's an interesting debate when selecting key position players - you can teach a player to kick, but you can't make them any bigger. Therefore do you lean towards a big player with all the attributes and attempt to develop that potential or do you lean towards a natural footballer despite size.

Stefan Martin vs Colin Garland is a perfect example.

If you could choose only one who would it be?

Stef Martin - great size, good build, good athelete - will have no problems against big bodies but will he turn into a player capable of damaging opposition sides?

or

Colin Garland - ok size, lean build, great athelete - natural player but will he probably always battle against big bodied fowards?

I guess you could argue that they will play different roles; however most of the year they were both given big tasks on key position players.

Could be an option for the rookie list.

I'd rather have Steven Armstrong on our Rookie List.

Wasnt Haydyn Kiel touted as the next Michael Voss at the start of this season?

lol vossy must not think so cause he chopped him off the list too?

Maybe thinks there's only room for one Vossy!