jane02

I agree. I am off to the game on Sunday with 14 Carlton supporters and my husband (Collingwood supporter). I am going to have to develop very thick skin for this one. I hope the boys give me something to cheer about. Even though most of the Carlton supporters are friends and work collegues, I am feeling a bit daunted.....

I fully agree with you.

Ok - we lost. How do we regroup and come out to face the Blues next week?

I agree - start playing the kids. I am feeling so despondent with today's performance.

Fantastic. Jim Keays has been a Demon supporter almost as long as me!

I also have a good feeling about today being our first win for the season. I also read Gary Lyon's article today with interest. I hope that the boys do us all proud. I have changed my plans today so I can be home in front of the TV at 4.40pm. Go Dees!!

Not flawed just honest about our list. I have looked at every other team and with lower draft picks than us they ALL have 3 or 4 really great players we have none. How many Melbourne players have been all Australian selections in the last decade easily the least of any AFL team-why? Look at our forward line Bate, Pettard and Dunn have had numerous chances and aren't good enough. Let's be honest we have the most mediocre list in the AFL.

Name one gun player recruited in the last eight years? The Carlton and Richmond players that I mentioned were all round one draft picks. Our round one draft picks have been Gysberts, Nathan Jones, Jack Watts, Matthew Bate, Cale Morton, Colin Sylvia, Lyndon Dunn, Sam Blease and James Seller. Hardly a consistent quality player amongst them. Therefore I blame the recruiters! Where is our Luke Hodge, Martin, Murphy, Penlebury, Cotchin, Ziebell etc, etc ...........????

Let's face it, in eight years and numerous first round draft picks, MFC has not achieved one gun player. In the same era that saw Carlton get Murphy, Gibbs and Kruezer, and Richmond get Delidio, Cotchin and Martin we have got Dunn, Pettard and Tapscott. Where was the foresight?????