sydneydee

Great appointment.

Time for goody to go with 18 months ago. I fear it is too late for this list and he will leave once we have truly hit rock bottom. My kids no longer follow AFL and I’m on the way out. i didn’t buy a family membership for the first time in decades last year and won’t buy a membership while he is at the club.

My kids are losing interest in AFL due to Goodwins boring game plan. He needs to go to save the next generation

Agree that both should be made accountable for this mess.

Yup, I rate Houston as a player but this sounds like poor list management. Take our top 10 pick to the draft.

Goody will not make in game coaching changes unless the game is already lost. That is my biggest criticism of him. He is stubborn and sticks to the system rather than tactical changes to maximise individual strengths.

We don’t want to get another rant from binman by blaming the coaches. It must be freos fault for being a better footy team than us.

I thought he played really well. I was really pleased to see some of his forward craft on display today. Still think it wouldn’t have hurt giving him 1 hit out at Casey.

Best of luck to Melks on his return. I’m failing to get excited by this match given what happened last time we played them.

I am not a Goodwin fan and think he has underperformed given the talent on our list. However I said “Goodwin and the match committee” My opinion is that both Goodwin and the match committee both have a poor track record of bringing players back underdone that has contributed to underperformance.

This is typical demonland herd mentality. For Melks sake I hope I am wrong but this smells like a Spargo rd 1 inclusion. You should not pick players unless they are cherry ripe. Melks hasn’t played in 10 months and is how 33 years old. Sorry chook but you have your head in the sand with this one.

Spargo - fail

Personally, I think this is a terrible decision. Melks should return via Casey to build his match fitness. Goodwin and the match committee continue to show they have no clue with their team selections.

Goodwin - must be sacked

With the worst coach is it a surprise?

Whilst Goodwins game plan is [censored], at least he is using a hard tag on daicos

They are putting their knee in at every opportunity. Why don’t we do the same?

Board doesn’t need to comment on last weeks performance. Where they failed was their lack of comment last year when Angus was physically assaulted by a targeted attack. I still don’t understand why we were not vocally outraged as a club and perhap that is one of the reasons why the playing group have lost their fighting spirit.

Goodwin needs to go. Our game plan needs to go and we need to recruit a proper forward coach.

Goodwin outcoached again. I don’t understand why we don’t use taggers like every other team in the league

Pissano is a small forward, so probably not her

I wonder if Goodwin put into time into the above players? Probably not as he plays a systems game plan when most other coaches effectively use a /several tagging roles each week.

Agree this is on the players but Goodwin has still butchered this list with his outdated game plan

Time to drop Goodwin to the VFL to see if he can execute his learnings.

Perhaps the Pies should be forced to pay his contract out of their cap.