Demon Dynasty

Where is this 'dangerous' KF view and coming in to replace Roo coming from? Merely suggesting he replace BBB for the Tiger's match at this point. He went pretty well vs Port up forward and as chop out ruck for Verral. BBBs done a great job to assist early but has dropped off the last few weeks from early season efforts for obvious reasons. Thats not to say BBB doesnt come back. But you need to trial / manage for alternatives if or when the opp arises. Now is a great time for that to occur. Also on 'dangerous' KFs i would argue we presently don't have one in a form sense. BBB, Roo & Petty have all been significantly off their best in this regard so far other than the odd cameo from BBB & Roo. Missed the point entirely

...repeat post

He's not competing with Verral imv Dee. Fullarton's a mostly KF type bit part ruck a la the role we're attempting to have Roo play. He has height on his side though and is as good as Roo in the ruck dept imho which isn't saying much i realise but you just want a contest. You don't have to have back up rucks dominating or winning most of the hit outs as such. Just neautralise as much as possible while Max is resting. Im not saying Fullarton would necessarily be more successful either vs Roo but having him in means we now have a 2 meter back up to Max (vs Roo 194cm) allowing a young / developing Roo to focus on what he needs to do best which is a KF crashing packs, pressuring as best as poss at ground level and also just bringing high balls to the deck if he is out of the contest. As much as i like BBB as the leading forward (when fully up and about, which he is not.... he's being nursed just to make it on the field each week) he doesn't offer the versatility that Fullarton potentially brings for Max AND Roo. Fullarton also matches BBB in the height dept at 200cm. There will also (highly likely) be no BBB in 2025. We have to start prepping for that and seeing who on our present list is capable ...or not! No better time than these sort of games (against severely depleted oppo) to do just that.

Couldn't agree more sir. These are the ideal matches (and vs North) to trial Turner / Fullarton & Rivers (into the middle until Clarry is 90% - 100%). If Clarry's hand is even 70% after having an opp roughly one week ago i'll eat my hat. I'll believe he's right to go when the glove comes off.

100%. I'd argue both are ready to go and as fit or possibly more (match ready) than both Petty & BBB based on their last few outings. Turner for Petty Fullarton for BBB Marty in for Clarry (to cover Rivers) Rivers into the middle

I don't think Dannyz would make the comment he made unless he had heard something pretty firm on the grapevine yes? IF this is another 2022 LJ situation then i'd much rather see us put more time into Fullarton in the short term from here. We could also trial other mediums that can play tall like smacca McAdam (once fit from approx end of this week) or of course Melk later when he's back. No matter what anyone says, if you've made the decision to move on, your body may be here but your mind / spirit has already left the building a la LJ in 2022. Playing Fullarton (at least in the short term) also frees up Roo from his chop out role for Max, allowing him to focus solely on his forward craft in order to get the best out of himself as a KF for the remainder of 2024 and beyond.

That'll teach you for stealing my tipping diary Chook

Biggest bunch of pretenders alongside Port

Really... pretty sure this is standard form for the AFL's franchise version of St Kilda

~ Sarcasm emoji missing ~

Who?

Stengles been puuurty good in this second half. Been in eveything. 2 goals

Haha... i would say mine but non of them are travelling to any Blues matches

MASSIVE throw by Neale there right in front of the ump. Ump puts whistle to mouth then withdraws .... "oh it's Lachie!"

Any relation WC!?

Are you kidding?? I can think of plenty of other decent outcomes. To both!!

Reckon Greene was fine until the last second when he turned his shoulder to bump. He should've curled up into a wrecking ball and ironed Durdin out. He would then get off... #AFLfootyAct

Thats the Giant's bubble burst. Toby done for a few weeks. VERY Hogan focused. Why they didn't move Toby into the middle at any stage is perplexing. Reckon they'll struggle from here to maintain momentum. Lions & Swans the next two weeks. Cripps / Walsh, two gun talls & Weitering down back makes the Blues a very difficult opponent to keep out of the game for long. Keeping in mind they had no Saad either who's a key intercepter and VG ball user off HB. Bah!

"Free kick Carlton" vs GWS... good luck with that Giants. The free to Hollands is a dead set 'tell' as to what's about to unfold

erratum...

One of them!!??

There's no way the AFL are gonna allow the filth to sit in the bottom half of the ladder. Umps over to you!

Lol surely at least one incorrect disposal in that stoppage against the filth?