Jaded No More

Any idea why?

So is 5 weeks with surgery a realistic timeline?

Like blaming Viney for Gawn’s injury in round 2. Stupid.

I was talking about Carlton being the second best performing side over the last month, along with us. Pies... pfft!

Danny > Edmund

Trac can steal this award now that Nicky is done for the year. Only 10 points between them, and we know Trac has 10 points in him... unless Clarry comes back and wants us to hold his beer 😁

Yes you are right, we have played one less forward in order to allow for an extra mid. I think we will drop the extra mid closer to finals once Clarry has settled back in, and go with another half forward, because we still have the option to play Kosi, Rivers and ANB through the midfield as needed, and we can push Gus back in case of dire emergency. I have a sneaking suspicion that Kosi is an ace up our sleeve that we are keeping for finals, where he will play greater on ball minutes. We don't want teams planning too heavily for it to happen, so we are using him sparingly now. But he hasn't trained with the mids in pre-season to play 2 minutes of midfield time a game IMO. So with that in mind, we will definitely need an extra small forward, which in all likelihood will be Spargo, unless Fritta is back and we choose to play him and Melksham together, with Melksham doing a defensive role on the opposition's intercept defender, which is important against the likes of Pies (Moore), Lions (Andrews) and Port (Aliir). The loss of Petty just throws off the plans of settling the back 7, because the forward 6 is back up in the air. Annoying and untimely!

Now this, this I can [censored] and moan about. Absolute rubbish luck. 0 stars.

There is no point thinking like that. We play a contact sport. He could have done this injury from a bullet pass that lands on his chest and McKay falls on him trying to defend it and his foot is caught underneath. He did a similar injury going for a mark against the Hawks.

Congratulations to the AFL for managing to organise 9 games with only 2 weeks left before the round is played. Thank goodness they did not screw us in the process and give us a short break AND travel all in one. It pays to be a good side!

The best defences are built on predictability. Smith has a bit of Frostball about him. He isn't predictable enough to the other defenders, and we don't have the luxury of time to get him settled down there. He doesn't know when to stay back and when to run off, and he isn't reliable enough to allow May and Lever to peel off and help one another. Tomlinson is slow but he's predictable. I think we are playing May higher up, because the plan is to have him replace Petty at CHB and have Tomlinson and/or Hibbo play closer to the goal line, where you need a 'goal keeper' style sweeper who can peel off and defend. Hibbo does this brilliantly well at ground level and in the air, but is obviously limited by height. Smith's attributes and unpredictability are better suited to playing as a forward IMO. With Clarry back *touch wood*, we will now have the option of dropping out a mid from the rotation, as we have been carrying an extra mid to cover his enormous loss. This will allow us to play a 7th defender, which could well be Hibbo, and free up Salem/Bowey/Rivers to play a more attacking role off half back. Alternatively we may choose to play an extra small forward to up the forward pressure and play a stronger front half game.

I agree, but their weapon is their contested work, which I feel we can better them in. I think Hibbo needs to play this week because their smalls are terrifyingly good at ground level, and our defence is not. A good week to play a small defensive group, and we always have Smith as a lever to pull down back if we need (he could even matchup on Curnow if we get desperate).

It depends how well they feel Adams is coming along, but I would say yes. We also have Jefferson coming along nicely up forward at Casey, so I would hope we target another tall defender. No doubt we will if Tomlinson leaves, plus Hibbo retires, and May is not exactly a spring chicken either.

So basically Mitchell 2.0 Bont or Trac deserve it purely for being elite for a long period of time and backing up over and over again (unlike Daicos... not yet at least). Would be thrilled for Bont to win it, he is the most influential player in the game in terms of being able to impact mid and forward. Trac is a close second... if he can kick straight. If Trac kicks a bag or two in the next 3 rounds he could pinch it. We could also have a tie.

You're right, he was in ok form, but in those rounds we played Hawks, Saints and West Coast and were also on a 10 game winning streak. I think his performance was helped by the opposition and how well we were travelling. We also had Ben Brown there so the need to rush him back was not as great.

I don't think people want Saturday afternoon anymore. Kids sports, work etc. Sunday afternoon is a better timeslot for families IMO.

You might want to ask @Webber our resident physio that

Taranto?? Are they drunk?

Big difference is that Tmac was in poor form prior to injury, and not in fact, solving our key forward issues by dominating up forward. We were also carrying too many players who were battered and bruised, so adding another one was too big a risk. I suspect we will push extremely hard to bring Petty back for finals. No chance we don't 'risk' him if we make a prelim and he's ok to play.

Which is why IMO they've been the second best performing side of the last month, aside from us. They are playing exceptionally well despite their injury woes. Port actually performed quite well too on the weekend considering their outs, but Geelong are also missing key players. Clarry in this week for mine takes the game from 50/50 to 70/30 our way. Because even if he's not in top form or touch, he is 10 times better than the alternative.

Goodwin was confident. Which means absolutely nothing. But apparently yes. Oliver getting around this week...

Best news possible. Just need everything to go right for once and no recovery setbacks! How confident are you of Fritta's return in round 24?

Doesn't really matter with a week off between finals. I prefer a 7 day break between round 23 and round 24 and I think so would the club. Chances are we finish 2nd or 3rd and therefore got the Saturday night game in week 1 of finals, with 1 v 4 generally the Friday night?

Is this 100% confirmed?

He rucked more than normal yesterday against 2 proper ruckman because we wanted to give Maxy a rest. I think Grundy is a big chance this week to replace Petty, which will allow us to play JVR as a permanent forward and not ruck. Smith may return to the sub role, with Tomlinson or Hibbo replacing him, so if Grundy is giving us donuts up forward we can sub him off for Smith.