old dee

Then why is he being droped every other week.

After todays news I am double downing on this problem.

So where does the blame stop? For better or worse at the coaches door. He has been at the MFC for a decade. The playing list and FD are all his chosen group. It ain't working so who else,s fault is it?

Why BA they beat us by 9 goals a few weeks back what has changed? We are still kicking terribly. With the exception of milkshake we have no forwards of any ability. Petracca looks like he wants to be anywhere but in a red and blue jumper and Clarrie is a shadow of earlier this decade.

The thing that depressed me the most is that it is all so MFC.

I think there is a big chance we have seen our last win for 2025. We simply cannot kick a winning score. It stands out what will happen between now and Mid 2026. We will lose most games for the rest of this season. We will go into next season with with a lame duck coach and FD who are being retained because we cannot afford to pay them out. More of this year's results will continue in 2026 why will they change? From April the questions will start like they have about Voss at Carlton. After a heavy loss in the KB game. The club will announce that Goodwin has been sacked. And another year will go down as failure.

So should we move to Tassie, it worked for Fitzroy?

Normally I would agree but I have sworn off all things USA.

Human nature says otherwise Mr. Leg. There is something amiss at the MFC at present, imo part of the problem is that too many things appear to be in holding mode.

Over rated. His performance at the top level does not justify the number of games he has played at senior level. He has however been treated like Lever, he missed a lot of the pre season with injury then straight into the side. Result poor games.

Or perhaps the FD are wishing and hoping.

If I was JVR I would be asking my manager to find me a spot elsewhere. This rucking is killing his development. In his second last game he spent barely 50% of the game as a forward. He spent 30% on the bench. What's that about?

You have my vote.

That pretty much covers it Jnr.

I disagree Dawes had concrete hands. Bounce in and out.

From what I have seen this year mr. Leg I would play Kentfield before Jefferson. He lóoks like he has intent. I never get that feeling with Jefferson. Jefferson is in his 3rd year and has played a handfull of good VFL level games. Time is up for me. There is however something amiss at the MFC. I smell discontent. Petracca looks like he wants to be elsewhere. Clarrie is playing to half his ability. What's happened to JVR. He is consistently playing below his first year. Of course it does help that he barely plays 50 of games as a kpf. He have a part time chief and a new one who doesn't start till the season is over. Add a future president who it appears was talked into taking the job Inspite of him having moved into retirement.

I think dominated is a bit high pf. He had a few good games. In his 3rd year he shows nothing at senior level.

Correct, I thought at the time it looked too early. Tmac was playing well at the time.

We are talking short term if we want to wins any games for the rest of 2025 we need Tmac.

Jefferson will never be ready. Struggles most weeks at Casey. Why do we keep playing Lever over Tmac?

Please don't say there is no one else by why do we play the last 4 they are not senior talents. Fritz was but a shadow now.

The seniors are no better 1 goal 6 at present

I watched part of the pies game last night. The problem is not the coach. Carlton like us are delusional about the quality of their list. They simply don't enough good players.

An excellent question WJ.

If you say so LDC.