First I'd like to say great analysis and great thread, but I'd like to do my own:
Defenders:
CP= Frawley, Grimes
GP= Garland, Warnock, Rivers, Strauss (could be CP), Cheney
DP= Joel Macdonald, Bartram, McNamara, Martin
Midfield:
CP= Scully, Trengove, Davey, McKenzie
GP= Moloney, Morton, Blease, Gysberts, Jones, Jetta
DP= I actually think that, given how young Jones/Jetta/Blease/Gysberts are, all of them could easily become great players and be in the best 22 every week, so no DPs here
Forwards:
CP= Jurrah, Watts, Tapscott, Petterd
GP= Bate, Sylvia, Green, Bennel, Fitzpatrick (almost CP, next KPF), Bail, Wonaeamirri
DP= Dunn, Miller, Maric
Rucks:
CP= Jamar
GP= Gawn
DP= PJ, Spencer
Maybe I could be a bit stricter, but this is my honest opinion