TheoX

Straight swap for Sam Blease?

Reunite him with his buddy Sculldog.

We definitely need some young key defenders, can't think of any on our list. If 2 of Dunn, Garland and Mcdonald go down we're stuffed (moreso).

I don't think chip can or will come out publicly with his decision to leave until the FA period opens. Similar to Buddy and Goddard. Until that time he'll still be making up his mind.

You need " " marks around making up his mind.

Only played 2 games with all the injuries the Pies had, can't have been doing too well at VFL level, pass for me.

Such a selfish [censored]

Don't know where you get the idea that McCartin is a Pedersen clone, he's nothing like him.

Just googled McCartin, didn't realise he had diabetes.

Not to mention Sandilands who has had two recos and Jay Schulz who has had one.

I've never heard of Sandi having had a knee reco?

After two reconstruction and now another problem it appears to me the big Max will probably not have a long future in the game.

At best he is now IMO a player with a limited future.

I find it hard to believe he will be playing AFL in three years time.

We need King to come on in the next couple of years

Our Ruck stocks now look like

Jamar At the end another year perhaps.

Spencer Similar to Max has had a number of serious injuries

King young and who knows probably needs 2 -3 years at Casey.

Does not look good to me!!

Eh, most clubs have 3-4 ruckmen, i't'll be easy to land someone who's at least serviceable.

He's a deadset dirty [censored]... I like that

He wouldn't get away with it if he was wearing red and blue though.

He'll be 30 in December. They should give him to us for free since we gave them Martin for almost nothing (thanks Neeld you Fwit).

Every player underperformed under Neeld worst coach I've seen. We were on an up with Bailey and should of kept him. I believe we would be in a better place now if we did.

Agree with the first statement.

Did chip turn up at Mad Monday

Just a cardboard cutout of his dopey mug.

Can we have a thread for all delisted players rather than an individual thread for each one.

No way, Patrick Wearden deserves his own thread.

We're in a vicious cycle now thanks to FA, we're [censored] so no one good wants to come, good players leave, we get shitter and so on and so forth.

Ugh, no way.

Would happily part with Frawley compo, assuming it's pick 3, if Malceski came in the deal.

His last ACL injury was thought to be just a meniscus injury until surgery, if I remember correctly. Not out of the woods yet.

http://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-premiership/melbourne-demons-confirm-young-ruckman-max-gawn-will-miss-entire-2012-afl-season-due-to-injury/story-e6frf3e3-1226224724290

right you are

Surely 2 of the T's will be staying put, their value is low low low at the moment. Tapscott though, he can go wherever or be de-listed.

Yep get rid of the filthy knobber

I am a stupid arse when it comes to this stuff.

What does that mean in dumb arse language?

Damage to the cartilage pad on the inner side of the knee joint. Dumbed down enough?

Yep, if it's an ACL, that will surely be career over. Hopefully it's not.

We had better get band 1 for this weasel, he shouldn't even be an unrestricted FA, how ridiculous is it that only the final year of his contract contributes to that status.

As I said MONTHS ago my word was that he is a signed and sealed CAT Make no mistake!

If we have any evidence of this we should demand the AFL investigate and have the Cats nailed to the wall for it.

Chipper was a complete liability last night Absolutley didnt care and played lazy rubbish football Let him go and become somebody elses problem

Thing is he will try his arse off at his new club, that's what makes it worse.

Was a bit weird seeing Frawley slink off the ground with his head down.

He would've been instructed by his new club to not get injured.