TheoX

Meh, unless 6 or 7 was to be used to get a superstar traded along with with 2 or 3, no way.

What a highlights reel. The guy is a big unit, and a good user of the ball. I don't think you could put together a highlights reel like that for Frawley.

Check out Blease's highlights. The guy's a gun!

Bottom 4 realistically.

Why am i thinking Rance like....???

'Cause he can't kick?

So the saints could've spun Membrey in to a Delisted FA (maybe because Sydney's list was full?) yet we couldn't do the same to Frost and therefore they could've pinched him.

As usual we are the ones getting screwed

All those last place finishes (well 2 of them!) and we couldn't ever get anyone of value in the PSD, except for Jetta, which turned in to it's own disaster.

Jurrah?

One of the best defenders in the game.

I wouldn't say he is/was the premier defender at Freo though. McPharlin and Johnson have him covered comfortably if you're just talking key defenders.

If I recall a young hawks and st kilda defender was smashed up early on by some big fwds. I think that young fella has played in 2 grand finals as the premier back in 2 teams and is one of the best blankets in the game who I also fing hate. Give him time.

Zac Dawson?

Is it just me or does he look way bigger than the 194cms he's listed at?

How so? There''s nothing to reference his height against in those photos.

Let's just wait until we see him play under Roos before making drastic, potentially career ending and downright evil statements about our recruiting team please.

There's no point screwing GWS when we are going to want to deal with them for the next few years as their kids keep coming home.

They're going to deal with whoever the plaeyr nominates/whoever gives the best deal, they won't give a [censored] that we bent over for them in this ridiculous trade.

Wow I can't believe we gave up pick 23 for him. Have we re-employed Barry Prendergast?

A key defender who was dropped for the last 7 games.

And only getting a game due to injuries to Mohr and Davis

As long as a trade for Membrey doesn't get done, I'm calm. Our hand might be forced if one does.

Strategically makes a lot of sense if they are chasing someone in the PSD. They can force us to use pick 2 on Frost and get whoever they want at pick 3. We might be targetting the same player. (speculation)

Yeah that makes sense, can't think of any player that it could be though.

When you see the other deals being done this week, I find it amazing that the club can't get this piddly little one done. Not getting at least one pick back for in the Clark/Lumumba and Garlett deals was a mistake.

Think we got pick 80-odd from the Garlett deal, GWS literally gave away Giles for nothing, so not sure why they're holding this up.

That is the real concern.

Surely we could put a high price on the 1st year of his deal, then just renegotiate teh latter years like Collingwood did with Luke Ball.

Sheesh, GWS traded Giles for a 3rd round pick swap in the 50s/60s, just give us Frost already.

If we're going to draft him I hope we get Richmond's medical staff to check his knee out.

Then you wouldn't have drafted the likes of Selwood or Judd? Although shoulders seem to be easier to recover from than knees (however Porplyzia would argue against that)

Or the likes of Scully

I'd rather we not draft injury prone players.

Obviously doen't always translate to the field, but a 3.2sec in the 20m sprint? Dang, Trengove ran sub 3sec. That's slow as hell.

Scully and Clark are synonyms for deceit and Pecksniffs.

SCully's a saint compared to the latter filthy piece of turd.

Trengove hasn't played for a year, and had a disappointing season the one before. His value isn't as high as many here would like to think.

True, but you don't sell low.

Could just tell GWS they can have our second rounder for their second rounder and Frost, or else we'll take him for free in the PSD. They get a mildly better pick and don't lose him for nothing.

Their second rounder is tied to that Steel bloke. Their other picks are 19 and 21 or soemthing i.e. before ours

Yeah they just traded a pick #2 from a couple of years ago for #19, how can they ask for 23 for Frost.

McCartin seems a much safer bet.

Yes it would cancel out our compo. So we will give mal a wide berth methinks.

Yeah, he's either staying put or more likely going to GC anyway. Don't think we're in the running.