Disco Demons

i'd have Green before Moloney....Green is melbs best kick for goal...could see him lifting the team with a captains goal one day!

in many ways he's just another Cam Mooney! Only difference Melbs midfield doesn't give him as many chances as the Cats Midfield...

ok...so your newton...you have just finished a the year in the reserves....everyone wants to trade you or delist you...you have a year left on your contract. somehow he makes it through trade week and ends up on melbs list for another year....wouldn't that be great inspiration to train super hard over the preseason and prove everyone wrong...the guy really owes it to himself...personally i think he's crap....but i would be happy to prove me wrong...for melb!

Newton is going to be next years Jamar! bahahahaha hahahahahaha

mcg would be a sell out for pia, scully & trengove round 1.

you'd think if miller had another contract we'd know about it by now...

i hope so...the more i hear about this guy the more excited i get.

if you had have read my original post you'd be able to answer those exact questions...

maybe we should just trade pick 1 for pick 7....happy to be corrected but isn't that the pick judd, rich, and co all went at?

how do you know for a fact home sickness will not be a problem with this bloke?

ha...i think you'll find i've used stats, available in the public domain to backup my argument/opinion...now for some reason...when someone doesn't like what i'm saying...they simiply turn to having a personal attack at me and clearly loose focus of what putting posts on this site is all about....thanks for reading my posts though.

tom is a nobody...tell him to go...see how far he gets...

nobody asks you to put posts on this site..but if u don't know your facts....then your really going to sound stupid...i get the feeling your not really as stupid as you sound...

your story was great....it gives me hope and belief...i wasn't alive to see melb win the last flag...i was at the 2000 GF...my whole family goes for Melb...we are the greatest club in the AFL...our time is coming...please continue your work! thanking you!!!!

Jamar has already turned 26 last month...but good on ya...for thinking he's awesome and younger than he really is...my first post gave the link to his stats..and his birth date fool...ha as this post has gone on...i have been the one to gain traction wit my argument....i've pulled out stats...people against me have only given opinion...at the end of the day...noboy gives a [censored] about your opinion in 100 years....but i'd be happy if it did...because that would be fair...as it would be on record...other than people looking at cold hard facts...

Jason Dunstall is not really a media commentator? he's on C-grade shows...he has no hair and people only remember his as a champ with hair.... i don't actually know wat shows he does...

i'm not saying PJ is the superior ruckman by any means....but the fact that PJ played more games that will be the assumption...just like u read into my comments...my point is...PJ played more games in the ruck...we now know 100% he's not a ruckman....jamar has played 7 games this year...are u 100% sure he's a champ or just improved? an improved player is great...but it's only going to take consistent games for the opposition to work him out...think about it... event though he's going to be to old for our premeirship challenge...do u want him still? i'm sure your a capable player...just like jamar

it's pretty funny people are having a go at PJ becuase he played 16 games and jamar has only played 7 games. in 100 years time for now...nobody will care that jamar played 7 games...fact is...PJ played 16 games and picked up the slack. Jamar has been a passenger all year and 'jamar lovers' luv him for it!

i know you never said PJ was crap...i understand you said he's not a ruckman... 'jacey' has said PJ has had a shocker year...many posts on this site about how crap PJ is... Acording to people who know PJ from playing with him around frankston he's a forward. that's where he's played most of his footy...i agree he's not a ruckman...

so PJ played 16 games and some people think he's crap...i think 16 games for the year is a reasonable indication of whether you can handle it at the top level. i don't think 7 games is enough games to be considered a performer. i would agree he has improved....but he's by no means a proven ruckman. I don't mind PJ... i'm in favour of trading jamar now...we did try and trade him last year...but nobody wanted him...i'd prefer to play a younger less experienced ruckman who would play like he has nothing to lose rather than a ruckman that has been on the list for 7 years...has confidence issues and injuries.

i was sitting behind the goals...and saw it wit my own two eyes....for an older player he does stupid things...

Jamar was an emergency for the blues game...amazingly kicked 5 goals. probably his most memorable of the 7 games. i watched jamar against the saints...had a brian snap against nick in the goal square and gave away a 50m right in the face of goal.. the guy has played above himself all year...do you really want carry someone who can only manage 7 games for the year...he's 26...next year he's 27....so that will make him 29/30...when melb should be pushing for a flag...therefore we trade him or he becomes #2 ruckman for someone else...again

he debut rd 1 2003...7 years ago...and has only managed 73 games.. 73 / 7 = approx 10 games a year....he's played 7 games...he's below avg this year by my book... he's a dud...

PJ = 16 games http://www.melbournefc.com.au/players/play...io/default.aspx Spencer = 6 http://www.melbournefc.com.au/players/play...io/default.aspx Meesen = 4 http://www.melbournefc.com.au/players/play...io/default.aspx ................. Hence PJ equals our number 1 ruckman of the year....

http://www.melbournefc.com.au/players/play...io/default.aspx According to this link Mark Jamar has only played 7 games for 2009 and kicked 7 goals...here's his stats for the year... So if Jamar is our number 1 ruckman who has been the number 1 ruckman all year? How has Jamar a much improved Ruckman if he only played 7 games.... I look forward to hearing from the Jamar lovers...