Dr. Gonzo

Yeah, good call BDA. You'd just love to see him get involved. /Lingy

Agreed, I thought he was on his last legs but he has been fantastic since returning to the side earlier this year.

I feel its been noticeably pathetic since 7 got the rights back from 9 and 10. Channel 7 no longer respect the sport, it's as though the game exists as a vehicle to get over 7's "personalities".

If a player does have prior opportunity they must correctly dispose of the ball.

I think it's because there is no prior opportunity - if a player is tackled without prior opportunity and the ball "spills free" in the tackle and the tackler doesn't let go it is holding the man. Goes against the spirit of the rule when the player just drops it though, should be play on probably.

That snap goal he kicked after having his kick smothered from the out on the full was pure awesomeness

He does that regularly as well, probably not last week but most weeks he does the stop, prop in traffic and lasers a pass inside 50.

His kicking inside 50 was elite

Viney completely shut out Wines tonight, he was very good.

Uphill skiers ⛷️

He was great. Brown in was so good for our structure even if he didn't do a tonne. Made life so much easier for T-Train and our small forwards.

Mate I started before the game CARNA DEMONS!!! Bloody good win, back to our best with pressure, TMac and Kozzie back in town with 3 each, Petracca back to his best May and Lever superb. Interesting Max confirmed they have had heavier training loads the last couple of weeks and it showed. Disappointing we couldn't get the points against Pies and/or GWS but we've responded now, top 2 with 6 games left, destiny in our hands.

It's so frustrating, watching the replay I reckon if Petracca nails that gimme shot a few minutes into the 3rd we win. He cannot miss shots like that from 35m out dead in front. Great thread @jnrmac its been quite noticeable that our pressure around the contest and in the forward line has dropped off markedly since the Lions game. Lack of pressure around the contest means we are playing from our back half and lack of pressure in our forward half means easy exits from our F50 and not getting those forward half turnovers that create scoring opportunities. The hope obviously is that Brown straightens us up, we start winning clearances/contests and Spargo, Kozzy & ANB (with help from Viney, Langdon, Gus etc) regain their earlier form pressure opposition defense.

.

Exactly - two Saturday Twilight games, one Saturday night and one Saturday arvo makes no sense. Crap timeslot, I hate Twilight games.

Joel Smith is terrible, I don't know why he is still on the list.

They were, I think they came on during the first quarter.

West Coasts #1 ticket holder isn't he? ?

On form you would drop Kozzie before Spargo, Spargo has been pretty consistent all year but was off yesterday. Kozzie has the potential to rip a game open but hasn't looked it in the last 3 games. Is it form? Or is he tiring after a sub-optimal preseason?

Yeah after watching the replay this morning he was better than I thought but his errors just stood out to me. He probably offers more than Sparrow at this stage so I'd drop Sparrow for Brown. Watching from the Southern Stand sometimes things that happen on the members side get missed which is why I like watching the replay even if we lose.

I watched the replay this morning as well and agree it was bloody frustrating because I genuinely think we were the better team for 3 quarters. They broke the game open in the 2nd quarter with 4 goals to 2 and we couldn't reel it in because our efficiency going forward was pathetic. Ben Brown will definitely straighten us up, so many kicks went deep in the first quarter and were just swept up by Haynes, Davis etc because we had no one there to compete. So many wasted attacks and obviously the last quarter was a debacle with Max, Rivers, Petracca all kicking the belly of the ball when trying snap, Petracca mjssing Gawn on a lead, Hunt failing to hit up Gawn in the goal square etc The start of the 3rd we came out with intent and stuffed up chance after chance, TMac missed an easy oass to Kozzie, Petracca misses a sitter, Fritsch misses a relatively easy snap. We should have been back on top after the first 5-10 minutes of the 3rd but had only 1 goal for our efforts, they then went down and kicked two quick ones to get the margin back out to 4 goals. Petracca's miss in particular was inexcusable, 30 out directly in front, a few minutes after half time. We've been saying all year failure to take advantage of our shots for goal will bite us in the [censored] and yesterday it did. I think it is clear from watching the replay that we are desoerately in need of a key forward (as many here said after last week) and I think if we had Brown in we probably win.

Harmes frustrated me yesterday, got caught on his left and held up momentum, handballed other teammates into trouble and dropped a couple of easy marks.

I thought that might be the case as well but a Goodwin comment in one of his pressers this week seemed to indicate this wasnt the case. Seems we're just in a bad form slump unfortunately.

Out - one of Harmes/Sparrow/Viney (in that order) In - Brown

Conversely every time we did get the clearance our guys were under immense pressure, handballing backwards, handballing into pressure etc