Old Gregg

Priority: Scully Round1: Butcher I just find a full forward so tempting...so what if he didnt have a great carnival, Butcher still looks a player.

Does anybody know where Jurrah, McLean, Moloney and Watts are at? How likely are they to return? Also Buckley. Sylvia and Morton definitely back in.

Deserve? Definitely. Need? I'm not so sure...we've definitely got a future, even without Scully et al.

Defs not. I pretty much forgot about the PP this arvo, I was filthy that he was paid the mark, and then kicked the goal.

6- McDonald 5- Petterd 4- Bate 3- Dunn 2- Grimes 1- Jones

35,922

Wow. What a game!!! I remember going in with some mates to the game AT HALF TIME!!! We just thought we'd go in for the hell of it, 50 points down, and then the second half!!! Inspirational stuff. Anyone who doubts the passion of the playing group for their club, have a look at that match. I'm amazed they were able to get themselves up after 7? losses to start the year, the laughing stock of the comp, and come out with a performance like that in the second half, astonishing stuff. Times like this that you miss Aussie the most...and you want Robbo to stay at the club. CARN THE DEES!!!

Well, this is my first time on the forum after reading for a while, so here goes. The obvious disapointments for me; injuries to Garland, Aussie, Blease, Strauss. Would have loved to see the former 2 build on their great seasons, and would have loved to see the latter 2 just get on the park for the Dees. But i reckon it'd have to be this whole bloody tanking debate. It just goes on, and on, and on....now, I see the value of Scully+Trengove/Butcher, and I'd love to have them at the club. But I want the Dees to win, so badly. I can't bring myself to barrack for "team tank". Why can't we just leave it at the fact that if we are not good enough, we will get two picks, and if we are good enough to win 5 games (which I dont think we are), we don't need pikcs 1 and 2 or whatever. The Footy Dept are going to stop at nothing to win; so be it. Nothing will change that. And I cant stand when people go on about being thrashed so our percentage is worse than Freo or what ever. I can see the tanking argument, I respect it, but thats too far. This debate has been the real disapointment for me.