Je Roos Salem

St.Kilda play Melbourne at Gold Coast first, and since it has seen the highest score in AFL/VFL history, I hope Melbourne don't lost by 204 points.

It's a joke that Sylvia is in the bests. He would have featured in the worst 3 that Triple M do.

How far away is Wonaeamirri?

I thought our pressure was great for most of the game. It was just not capitilising.

McLean's stats do look very good on paper. His disposal effeciency was good enough, at 81%

Yes, but he has spent far too much time in the midfield in the past year opposed to the start of his career.

Sylvia shouldn't go. He is still a conmponent of the club. I still think Sylvia can improve. He needs to spend more time up forward I think. He tries to overdo it in the midfield.

When Robertson comes back we are definitley capable of kicking a winning score. I thought 14.6 90 was a good effort in the end today goalwise. Better than 10.7 against North and 10.4 against Collingwood. in total we have kicked 34.17 for the year- which is good accuracy. Not enough goals but still accurate. But compare it to the opening three rounds of 2008 where we kicked 27.36 in total. We have obviously improved our kicking skills and set shot kicking by a lot and I have seen that in the first three games from people like Miller and especially Green. The main problem with our forward line is positioning.

Lade was the one being stupid. He ran after Morton like a maniac.

You forgot to include forwards, Brad Miller in paticular, must always lead in infront of his opponent.

Yze I don't understand what you have against Cameron Bruce. Last week you were saying the same thing about "junktime" stats.

Yea I hope so as well. We can't afford any more defenders to go down like Warnock or Frawley. Does anyone know how McDonald is progressing?

Jetta should stay in the team for another few weeks at least.

I thought McLean played OK, he just still needs to be more influential.

I hope Jetta plays next week. He has the potential but needs to find ways of getting the ball and contesting. I thought he played well in the first quarter but then he completely dropped off.

PJ played a shocker, the best thing he did all game was see the ball over the boundary line. I think he will play next week, due to the fact that Bailey might not risk playing two young and inexperienced ruckmen.

All Bate needs to do now is become consistent. He needs to kick 2 or 3 goals on a weekly basis and if he can do that it will help the forward line by a long shot.

Love to hear everyone thoughts. My thoughts: Maric and Wonaeamirri both in (if fit) Out- Dunn, Sylvia

Martin is quick for his size, but Martin's main fault is when possessing the footy he is sometimes unsure of what to do.

Geelong are a top team, but Carlton aren't I think we can beat the tigers as long as we can take Richo out of the contest which we partially did last time (even though we lost by 80 points). The Dees will be back at the G and ready to fire

Bate's kicking may not be great, but he showed some great signs toward the end of the game like taking a great contested mark. That is what we want to see. If Bate can keep taking those marks that we desperately need inside our 50, kicking skills can come after.

Sylvia's commitment to contests is terrible. He got 14 possessions, five marks but hopefully he can have another go next week.

6-Davey 5-Bruce 4-Green 3-Moloney 2-Morton 1-Bennell I put Bennell in because he showed plenty of promise and dash during the game. I would have put Jones in if he hadn't made a couple of stupid mistakes (like that shot on goal).

Alright guess by me: 20,557

I thought our forwards didn't give a big enough effort for four quarters. There were plenty of times when the ball was kicked inside our forward 50 and a Port Adelaide player was in front.