Everything posted by Cheap Seats
-
Eddie McGuire Steps Down Effective Immediately
It might be surprising but many actually volunteered. Now Military strategy on the other hand is actually quite interesting.
-
Eddie McGuire Steps Down Effective Immediately
My mistake, it was a quote from her book
-
Eddie McGuire Steps Down Effective Immediately
You forgot the Spanish, Ottomans etc. Correct me if Im wrong but the Spanish have the lavish claim of settling a continent and the inhabitancy disappered? There is a little known history of British enslavement where the Brits themselves were taken as slaves, very exciting stuff.
-
Eddie McGuire Steps Down Effective Immediately
The relevance here is that we are lucky to be in a country that allows us to discuss matters in a free and respectful way and not be dictated to by Governments or anyone else on what we can or can't say.. As some Pom once put it "I disapprove of what you say, but I will defend to the death your right to say it".
-
The five players you want to have an impact in 2021
Don't take it personally i am just having some fun. Give me a best 22.
-
The five players you want to have an impact in 2021
Not enough players in your best 22?
-
2021 Full Fixture
I think our record of going to Perf to play the E Girls is just as good
-
Unpopular Opinions - Melbourne FC Edition
Id still take Watts with the number 1 pick.
-
Nick Hind
I definitely understand that. It's all about Gil filling his pockets with ad and tv revenue.
-
Rumour only file ...
Same. I thought there maybe some good info. Turns out no, there isn't.
-
Nick Hind
I understand that. It just makes you wonder why have a deadline if it's not really a hard deadline. What is the definition of a completed deal? Why should they be allowed to f around for so long ad leave until the end?
-
MFC Trade Summary
Any word on Jordan or any other OOC players? Any ideas of the DFAs we might look at? Cheers PS love your work @CHF thanks for the info
-
Tom Phillips - Outside Skills and Speed
Low payments or not, the fact still stands they hold all of the barging power. The fact still remains they are well paid in relation to average joe, and fact is the AFL doesn't have the hitting power (flow of dollars) of major league's you're probably referring to. Either way it's the AFLPA are the ones pushing for US style Free Agency rules (see quotes from AFLPA reps like Dangerfield and Pendlebury) and if that's what they want then things like public knowledge of salary and being traded against their will is also a big part of that. Otherwise the goodwill lies with the clubs. I don't buy the AFLPA and players argument, if they f over the fans they will end up with nothing
-
Nick Hind
Pretty much. The AfL will justify it, but essentially the deals were not done and shouldn't stand. Apart from the obvious lack of AFL integrity, it probably doesn't really matter
-
Tom Phillips - Outside Skills and Speed
There is a lot that happens behind the scenes we dont' hear about. For example Hawks and Phillips could have been in discussion and Phillips told the Dees he wasn't interested. One of the key flaws in the AFL FA system is the player has to choose the club, not the other way around.
-
Hopes for the final trade day
If we lost them all out, what players will there be left to bag @olisik?
-
2020 Player Reviews: #23 James Jordon
Sounds like something we lack badly. I really hope we keep him, but seems strange if we rate him so highly why he isn't signed yet.
-
Rumour only file ...
Would do that without thinking. Im a huge fan of Vanders but reality is list sizes are biting and we need speed and class.
-
Rumour only file ...
Yep I think clubs are trying not to cut too hard but there will be some tough decisions made. As public as Collingwood have been and to a lesser extent the Dees with TMac i reckon all clubs are carrying some sort of bad contract and are looking to cull as much TPP as possible. Interestingly trade news has mentioned TMac as still a huge chance of moving. I personally don't see it happening but we will wait and see. I trust @CHF info, i reckon the dees are restructuring TPP and we will see some tough decisions made in the short term.
-
Rumour only file ...
I think i heard Hewitt (im not 100% sure), has been offered around by the swans.
-
Rumour only file ...
There were reports swans had cap issues aa well. Wonder if that is holding up a lot of deals and the reason why there isn't much movement.
-
Rumour only file ...
At least @Nudge put some excitement in to this trade period. There isn't much happening
-
Chad Wingard
Ive bwen a member 20 something years. If we trade anything for this guy I'll hand it in.
-
TMac on the Trade Table?
Poor Tom. Mind you i reckon Toms a better player than Wright. Essendon clutching at straws. Mind you if no one wants Tommy I'm happy we keep him. Get fired up Tom come back fit and tear it up.
-
Rumour only file ...