beelzebub

The real question isnt why Oscar instead of Hore, it's why Oscar at all as he's no valuable role or matchup. On the other hand Hore DOES have something to add to the equation. They are separate concerns

Thankyou...someone who understands.

Good for you I have my OPINION Its not yours. Deal with it. Your opinion is as well only that Ive also listened to Macca. Ive also spoken with people who ought to know what they're on about. I for one am happy enough he's going...I only wish he'd take most of the rest of our fn useless FD with him. Have a nice day

I was answering to ManDee Beyond you ? Couldn't give a rats one way or other what Macca says or sees.

Melbourne doesn't tank....we just play that badly.....

FD has no [censored] idea Pies by 30+

heres me thinking PwC was Parents without Children !!!

Totally agree. Knowing Melbourne. ..it'll be a brutal reckoning.

Strangely....youre actually correct. Many are making curious and erroneous evaluations as to the real worth of some in the FD. As you oddly allude....many assumptions are being made.

I've always thought StKilda a strange beast. Bit of a Bermuda triangle of Footy. I would certainly like Richo at Melbourne...quite happily have him as SENIOR coach actually.........

Nicely devilishly advocated. Actually ...no. He's vermin. I would not give my money to a club that employed him.

Id burn my membership first if that scum every became part of our club.

Up ????? arrrrghhhhhh lol after this year will be lucky to only LOSE 8K

Good rationale. ..re players. I fear it's another Melbourne 2/3 - 3/4 worth of game coming up. Unlike us.. they'll come to play and refine ahead of finals.

We aspire to being 'scarcely' relevant !! By Joves we'll get there ....or bust !!

quite possibly a good scenario. Not sure it was Brendan's gig though. And he might have scared some of the kiddies !!!

give the man a cigar

i dont think a lot of people quite understand how ahead of his times Norm Smith actually was. In his day he was NEW school. Personally Id love to have Smith coaching us.

good summation

He had said he'd have liked to see our his footy days at the MFc. His nature doesn't suit all. Has a very singular idea about footy. This has been shown to ultimately not be an overly successful one ( not hust with us ). I know for a fact hes not liked in certain circles...but others praise him. This is a huge change for us. A positive one. Positive because it will act as a catalyst for more changes. Keep going Melbourne. ..get that broon busy.. lots more to sweep out the door.

Sorry mate...you couldn't be further from reality here if you tried.

On MFC fb page

I rate Richo as better than Goody... considerably. Maybe as a duo we might start plsying footy...real footy....not current rubbish.

You just made my day

Bad ol' Collingwood will win , easily by the end...because, well..... They know how to play the game......... and I'm far from convinced that we do....