Jump to content

whatwhat say what

Life Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by whatwhat say what

  1. well, apart from the fact that we - currently - don't have a rd 1, '22 pick
  2. i was under the impression the aints' nga picks are around that 15-30 range? some thought that marcus windhager may go inside the top 20, precluding them from matching a bid, a la mac andrew for us
  3. i cannot fathom why north wouldn't make the filth and footscray pay up for daicos and darcy
  4. whatwhat say what replied to Turner's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    the 'conversations' about finlayson going back to south australia started three months ago the request from hill to be traded to one specific club in victoria started four days ago it was always an ambit request that required gw$ getting 'cover' for a small forward particularly important with greene on sabbatical for the first five weeks
  5. i watched q1 vs freo and then q4 premiership - it's chalk and cheese (roquefort?) from a comparative standpoint the quality of our improvement in football was extraordinary over the course of the season
  6. showing my bias but would have lever over moore and langdon over dawson, personally also would prefer a genuine 'defender' over daniel
  7. i wish nothing more than mid-table mediocrity upon them
  8. howie kotton is an old school football journo - if he's saying it it's going to happen
  9. helluva player rated super highly internally but not nearly enough externally
  10. the obvious answer is oliver given the amount of games he's played, his age, and his durability thus far left field option could be charlie spargo
  11. what a career he had can't wait for his kids to be in red and blue in 20-odd years
  12. bang bang. bang. bang.
  13. brayshaw and may
  14. the feeling of panic when he did his hamstring in the prelim was my worst football-related feeling in 2021
  15. whatwhat say what replied to Turner's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    bobby hill has shown a lot of promise in his first 30 games, but i can completely understand why we would prefer someone like kade chandler who we've had in our system for the last several years and is a 'next best fit' selection over a prospective pick-up from another club
  16. is this the same mick malthouse who writes utter garbage in the little paper and talks complete rubbish on aunty? fraser might've been 'belted up' but he was the #1 ruckman from the get go in a side that was a regular finals side and he played in excess of 200 games across a 13 year career, was vice-captain of his club, and more than held his own as #1 ruck over the course of his time
  17. josh fraser was picked #1, was his side's #1 ruckman from almost his first season in a regular finals outfit and in consecutive grand finals, and played over 200 games across the course his career - it's a complete myth that he was 'belted' early because, like jackson, he was an expert reader of the ball and knew how to position himself to be effective not just as a ruckman but almost as a ruck-rover type due to his athleticism for mine, the closest comparison jackson has is as an oversized adam goodes - he can play ruck, midfield, forward, and potentially on the wing too a true 'utility' in the old way of thinking
  18. whatwhat say what replied to Demonland's post in a topic in Melbourne Demons
    so next year it'll be 7 players taking pay cuts!
  19. i am still pissy he was ROBBED of a possession by champion data's bean counters and the sole mantle of being the #1 possession getter in a premiership
  20. like most folks, i don't see him going anywhere there was some talk from an actual reliable source - it may even have been jake niall? - that his parents are actually looking to move to melbourne
  21. i would all the talk is that he's firming for top 10 if not top 5 i think the immediate success we've had with luke jackson has changed the attitude to prospective hybrid ruck / forwards
  22. is he a titch 'small' for a modern key position tall? they're more and more around the 200cm mark...