Bates Mate

He will be a good player. Lots of upside

100% agree. of interest how would we get him. Pre season draft.

Id go Lockhart Has got footy smarts and good disposer. Ideal long term replacement

Would be embarrassing if we go all out and try get him to the club and match salary etc and he still chooses Carlton. Gotta have a crack though

We obviously rated Langdon higher who plays the same role. Based on the last 2 years I think we went after the right guy.

This kind of optimism had no place in demonland. Are you a new supporter? ?

Not a fan. Both have been underachievers and looked a bit soft IMHO

What would the Hawks give us? Hawks have Pick 11,30,50,87. Pick 30 is about right I think , 50 is Unders of the back of his 2019. This is where Mahoney and co need to be smarter when discussing our own players during trade week. Talk them up even if you don't rate them helps drive up the price. We suck at this

He was great in the first 2-3 years with us then got "Melbourned"

The now Collingwood version not the soft turnover merchant version we had in his last two years with us.

That makes zero sense. So do Judd's comments about gc getting pick 10 .

For a Jeffy level pick in the 80s for hell yeah. Anything in 1st 3 rounds not for me

No the only plays well against the dees club. Membrey also a member

100 percent you have to put it out there and see what bites you get. Happens every year with club's who have decent picks

He is an honourary member of the Kent Kingsley club, he is a no from me

Ablett in the squad is a joke He had been ok had some decent moments and games but nowhere near best 40 performing players in the league

We need forwards who apply pressure and stuck tackles. Jeffy store doing this 3 years ago and shield the hard stuff everytime.

We have to be the worst handballing team by far miss the target 80% of the time

At the very least he can offer advice to Goody on how to handle constant speculation about your job

Latest report saying Saints are into him for 900k per year. He is a good player but I think that's overs

We can close this thread

The tank is real

Played a great QTR give him a break ffs

Our field kicking skills were the best I've seen us all year that qtr

Embarrassing . Bruce and membrey take out the Kent Kingsley cup