kozzyisalegend

Do we have a first rounder this year

Wouldn't call it a bust, but he seems like a very similar player to viney, Oliver, sparrow. Big physical body without the athleticism or outstanding skills. But he has the competitive side that we lack

Lack of defensive running/urgency. Refusal to get to the right spots and work hard

Also our prime kicks ala rivers and bowey were shanking it constantly.. their development has really stalled

Bit of a confusing list decision to bring him in ...

Anyone but BBB or petty please

Whilst I think koltyn has to come in, he really didn't have an afl standard game in the 2s on the weekend. The disappointing thing has been at casey all year no one is pushing for recall

Why not recruit someone like sharp instead of billings? He looked real good

One thing I must add about petty is the effort is lacking

Windsor has really slowed down past few weeks, looks tired Would love him to clean up his disposal a bit

Mabior chol would've been handy in the fwd line today

From memory we gave schache and laurie a contract extension and billings is on a 2 year contract

Flynn gentile

Division B in vafa. Played 5 games , in the best twice. You'd hope as an afl footballer you'd be dominating vafa

Played vafa I think, can't seem to make the vfl side....

Fyfe is cooked Brayshaw, serong are both gun players We had the chance to draft young but elected to pick a WA boy who checked out half way through his stint at Melbourne I don't understand why Goodwin let harmes Jordan and Grundy walk. Having those 3 in our squad now would be a big help

I'm just surprise the club opted for a project tall who will take a few years rather than a ready made mid who can play day dot and contribute to our midfield depth which is clearly lacking

It's the non effort that be didn't call out

Should be in red and blue

May would great for a switch with petty

Goodwin would rather have billings over jordan

Wouldn't you say that mid season draft was an opportunity for a quick (but not complete) fix?

Got the best ruckman in the comp 2 all australian midfielders A contested beast in viney Yet we continuously get destroyed in contested possessions and clearances Why? Is it set up? Or are they just not very good ? Or is it effort ?

I don't mean to knock the kid, but the decision to draft kentfield is bizarre. I just don't get it

3 biggest whipping boys at Melbourne Schache Billings Mcadam All new recruits. Wonderful from JT