old55

Ridiculous logic. He's not staying at North and he hasn't nominated any new club yet. Maybe he's going to nominate for Elon Musk one way trip to Mars?

North will have salary cap to burn. They don't need to get Polec's salary off their books, they'd rather pay some of it and get early picks.

With Smith to Geelong this thread needs to be on page 1. Brown + Polec for 2021 1st?

"Needs to be stronger in the contest"

Hopefully he meets Vanders head on next year.

Yep confirmed campaigner.

Cats wings have Menegola, Duncan (or is he more primary mid now?), Blicavs plays there and Clarke can't get a game. Smith doesn’t seem a major need.

Spargo improved his tackling and kicking depth this year. He's got further scope for improvement. I prefer him to Hunt and ANB fwiw.

Port looking for a KPD and aren't getting Aliir. Maybe TMac there? They were suspect against tall fwds this year with a high % of goals conceded to them - see game plan thread for details.

Josh Mahoney to Essendon?

I believe #55 is the lowest number never to play a senior game.

Gee how does Adem Yze get to join this "inner sanctum" then?

Yes May-Petty for Hawkins-Cameron with Lever free to intercept or 3rd man up for the spoil. Dangerfield or Martin forward is a different problem.

If we get Ben Brown, then Harrison Petty.

And we definitely don't need a post from you in every new player thread telling us what we need.

How about they give us the Lexus Centre and we'll take on his entire contract?

This is well supported when you look at the Richmond BnF - role players ... Jayden Short, taken as a rookie six years ago, edged out superstar Dustin Martin to win the Jack Dyer Medal. Nick Vlastuin, Shai Bolton and Kamdyn McIntosh rounded out the top-five in another Tigers premiership season.

I didn't hear that but I saw it. Insufficient agility to make it as a pressure forward. Move on.

You can trade the future 2nd in addition if you can get one back from somewhere else, e.g. last year we traded future 1st and 2nd to North but got a 2nd back from Hawthorn for Frost.

No if we trade future 1st we can't trade any other future picks and vice versa.

Would you do Brayshaw for Billings? https://www.footywire.com/afl/footy/ft_player_compare?playerStatus1=A&tid1=12&playerStatus2=A&tid2=16&type=A&pid1=4037&pid2=3920&fid1=C&fid2=C

@Ethan Tremblay is a spoof account from the username, to avatar and humourous posting. He might rightly satirize and few full on posters now and then. It get tricky for him when he want to make a serious point.

Congratulations to the Martin Football Club on their 3rd flag. Dusty has a strong claim to GOAT and he has a few years ahead to cement it. Those 4 genius goals from nothing were magic. Richmond might have one flag without him. I'm the bearer of unpleasant tidings this week but the fact is that to win that GF, after that pre half time resuscitation goal from Dusty, Chris Scott needed to instruct Blitz to come off the line Mark Yeates style at the start of the third. Dimma couldn't complain because it's straight out of his playbook.

Here's two unpopular opinions: I like Dangerfield. He's a great player, great to watch and he gives his all. I don't blame Scully for going to GWS. We were a disaster area and the offer was just too big to refuse. He would have been mad not to take it. I don't buy the "lying to big Jimma on his deathbed" lament either, Scully was in a no win situation there.

The problem with your posting is that you're the king of criticism and the pauper of solutions. You've got nothing except critique.