Bring-Back-Powell

100% spot on.

A lot of that is correct aside from hoping to lose and cheering on the Pies.

I assume that’s a joke. What a false dawn that win was against us in round 2.

I get the impression people don’t rate Collingwood because they hate them more so than actually analysing their list and the way they play, which is strongly suited to the modern game. I firmly believe Collingwood will be there on prelim final weekend, at the minimum.

CELEBRATE is too strong a word but it might be one week closer to a new direction that these players and supporters desperately need.

If he and Kozzie can kick 4.2 instead of 0.6 between them, we might be able to have a conversation. Can we at least kick more goals than behinds tonight?. All 4 teams in Gather Round have managed a combined 43.24 in these better than perfect conditions.

He dropped those sitters after I posted the suggestion so it didn’t age well. The point still stands that he’s a viable forward -ruck “30 goal a year” player that we should hunt this off season.

Fair call GW.

In a parallel universe that saw us got Chris Scott, our membership would increase from 50,000 to 70,000 at the click of a finger. One of the sharpest minds in the recent years. A coach that keeps evolving Geelong from a 1 year dip to constant finals, prelim finals and premierships. And of course the ability to attract A grade talent in Cameron and Bailey Smith. He’s also brilliant in press conferences.

Agreed they lost to GWS badly, but they’re building into their season nicely. And Bulldogs and Sydney are definitely not mug teams who they’ve beaten.

Rjay, they’re going better than ok. They’re 4-1 with an absolute stack of MCG games to come. They’ll likely finish top 3 and if they can avoid Brisbane at the GABBA in week one, they probably play in this years GF.

Not Goodwin related. Why can’t we bring the elite pressure that Collingwood bring most weeks, especially tonight?

How’s Hayden McLean’s availability at the end of the year. A viable second ruck that nails difficult set shots.

Slightly surprising we didn’t aggressively pursue him, assuming we didn’t. If Collingwood knock off Brisbane at the GABBA next week, they go out right premiership favourites in my book. Watching the game live they have that prefect balance between attack and defence.

Is it coaching or our playing list? If Jordon’s tagging Naicos he isn’t doing a great job. Minus 7 in possessions and on track to concede 30.

We’re unacceptable at the moment GW. Obviously every thread is going to have a negative slant.

I’m flabbergasted beyond belief that people tipped Collingwood to miss finals. The most obvious rebound year imaginable.

Head over to the “Time to Go Goody” thread at 9:40pm local time.

Adelaide almost kicked half of our total season goal tally in one night. In a loss.

In fairness, the way Geelong smacked Freo in round 1 at GMHBA and proved their bona fides last night against Adelaide with a few best 22 out, I’d suggest a lot of teams would’ve lost by 6 goals to Geelong last week, like we did. Sometimes it all it takes is for a horribly out of form team to put in an improved effort in terms of being in the game for 3 quarters and they then reference that as a turning point going forward. We were objectively better last week for 3 quarters until our mistakes and lack of forward options did us in. However we just can’t kick a winning score with this current squad and don’t have the forward line to rectify this IMO.

A new day and the selections are still baffling. I normally don’t get too upset with selections but this week has gotten to me. We have the worst forward line in the league and he’s done literally nothing to address it other than drop Turner who is one of the rare players on this list that can nail a set shot to save himself. I’m assuming Petty’s playing forward this weekend. Otherwise we’re going to have a forward line that will contain literally zero key forwards when JVR’s rucking or on the bench. And they’ll be talking about the chronically maligned Ben McKay being the best key defender in the league for a week.

I still can’t work out the Fullarton non selection. What kind of message does it send that you can kick 10 goals and take a bunch of marks in 3 VFL games but still not get selected in the AFL’s worst forward line? Once again we’re setting JVR up for failure as he has to lead this impotent forward line. Yet, furthermore we also drop a player who actually has an ounce of goal kicking craft and isn’t allowed to string 2 games together while others like Sharp and Spargo have a golden pass off doing next to nothing this season. I’m really concerned where we are heading under Simon Goodwin.

Maybe Petty starts up forward. Been objectively bad as a defender the last 3 weeks and perhaps we only need 2 tall defenders for Draper and Caddy

A real “phone it in” effort at selections by Goodwin and Co. Tell me who’s going to be our key forward when JVR is rucking or on the bench?

And the AFL's love of Carlton sees them involved in the weekend's 9th ranked interesting game at Adelaide Oval.