BDA

Ben Brown, Weiderman and Petracca

Umpiring is difficult because the rules keep changing. Firies, health workers, police and defence forces all have it much tougher though

Nah QD. One more good preseason and the rest of the comp better watch out ?

for people who bang on about culture and having the right characters dusty martin

until dusty retires we're all playing for 2nd.

only decent supporter they have is ash barty. she's a little champion.

as hard as you'd see. hope he's ok

another norm smith for dusty. he's a freak of nature.

all over red rover. geelong can console themselves with cameron

hawkins not much better

wrong thread

cats needed that

after all geelongs dominance just 9 points in it. far from over this one.

Why can't they just get Barnsey

Fwits

dumb

JOrdan Clark showed plenty of dash in the sprint. an option for our wing perhaps!

i realised 10 mins before the game. I'm watching on afl live pass on my mobile

looks like your wish will be granted

Tougher for the Vic teams. Easier for SA and QLd. Port and Brissy will never have a better opportunity

I’m not one for tradition for traditions sake but I think the gf should remain a daylight game. Every year I fire up the BBQ and have friends and family over to watch the game. With the public holiday added now its makes for a great family orientated weekend. I think a night time slot would change the whole dynamic for the worse.

I find it hard to dislike players we traded out. Jesse, Kent even Watts when he had that blinder against us in round 1 2019 I couldn’t bring myself to curse him. The exception is Scully. Can't stand him.

I wish Melbourne could reach Geelong's level of overratedness.

I’m wide awake Billy You seem to be unfamiliar with some of the basics of trading. The idea is to exchange items of equal value. The objective is to achieve a win win scenario whereby clubs exchange players which fill a need and improve their list overall. I think Harmes can be very effective in a defensive mid role and is worthy of a spot in the best 22. Brayshaw is worthy as well, has talent no doubt but has been inconsistent. If the club has to trade to fill a need then I think trading Brayshaw for a winger or KFF would deliver a greater overall result than trading Harmes. Hence my post. For future reference I’d prefer if you respond with an argument why you think trading Brayshaw is a bad idea. Or with an argument why Harmes should or shouldn’t be trade rather than a pot-shot. I’m happy to hear your thoughts.

look to bring in josh kelly or Zack Merrett with the oliver picks