Billy

Your votes shouldn't count if you don't have TMac in there

6. T Mac (Those of you who didn't have him in the votes "WAKE UP") 5. Clarry (Darcy who???) 4. Watts (Getting consistent) 3. Pederson (Welcome back) 2. Lewis (Welcome back) 1. Viney (Played the ball instead of the man)

Did Bradshaw play?

Who kicks goals for us Sunday? Who plays on Daniher? Who rucks? Who wins?

What a load of dribble, he's had an interrupted pre season, has been one of most consistent players since he joined the club.The people in the know seem to regularly have him there about in the B&F

I'd rather a key back or a ruckman. Nevs up there with the best small defenders in the game

Tyson had 16 inside 50s for Casey, that's a belter! Tyson for Silly Bernie Pedo for Smith So Oscars our fall guy this year is he? He stays. Running out of options in the backline which is a bit of a worry.

Don't stick your neck out at all?

You're right that is meaningless ?

But you're making it sound like a major issue. Give the guy a break, if it was anyone else on our list we would be making excuses or saying it's a non issue. Hopefully he plays the next 2 practice matches and then has another top 5 in the b&f. Storm in a tea cup!!

Love it, and Trappers finish, how did we lose that game!

I have no doubt that Jack has great leadership on field and on the training track, but leadership is just as important in the public forum these days as well. He didn't sound ready on that side of it to me. Thats just my opinion Wiseblood, I'm sure you and the club knows better (I hope)?

Yep spot on

Viney was onSEN116 this morning. He just doesn't seem ready yet, nothing against him at all, just think it's a burden he could've done without for a year or two

I agree Chunk doesn't sound to happy & l don't blame him

Fair enough, but he can still do that as the sole captain

So what, just because Sydney has done it and Roos coached us means we have to do it. Move on

This club does some stupid things!!!! Chunk took over the captaincy when the club was on its knees and has done a brilliant job What do they do, just as we are coming out the other side, instead of (hopefully) Chunk getting some well deserved credit they kick him in the guts. Why coulldnt Viney be VC??????

Don't like it, Chunk deserves it for a couple more years. Why not Viney as VC until Chunks ready to hand it over 2 captains?????

Would love that team Rd1

Hi everybody 1st time long time? Im a bit confused with all the hype about StKilda. They will beat us, that's a given but l don't think they will be as good as us, does that make sense? I think our running defenders are better, midfield bats deeper and forward line is better. If we can stop their No12 who normally tears us apart (surely he'll be slowing down!) there should be no reason why we can't finish above them