dazzledavey36

I would prefer him spending the whole year down at Casey educating and developing our younger forward crop. But I agree, if he plays it means we've been absolutely decimated with injuries 2019 style.

Reminds me of a bigger and taller Lachie Neale.

The rate he's going he'll be lucky to get on an AFL list. Top age next year so still water to go under the bridge but he'll need to put in a big off season to put himself into draft calculations.

Haha okay mate

Retire Brown. Can't afford to carry a player that is constantly missing games each year due to cooked knees. I'd happily trade/retire McDonald but I think he stays purely for depth and being a long time servant of the club they'll want to do the right thing by him.

This you as well? Strike rate about at about 0.2%

Aren't you well known on here over the years for completely making stuff up and having a zero strike rate??

All the best Jimmy.

In regards to?

All that death riding of Freo now just seems a waste purely with North compensation. Absolute joke. Didn't realise McKay had turned into Steven Silvagni ll of a sudden.

In fairness to Smith he's been completely played put of position his whole career down back. It's only this year the coaches decided to wake up and realise his athletic traits is best suited up forward.

You're kidding right?

That's absolutely not treating him poorly but okay.. in fact Jordon should count himself lucky he was still able to get senior opportunities ahead of someone like Dunstan who was banging on 30 plus touches each game. When he got his opportunity playing full games he was incredibly disappointing. In fact Goodwin even gave him a stretch of game to try and prove himself and he failed to do so, so back to the VFL he went. Goodwin did the right thing. How did he go in his recent performance against Carlton when he was given another full opportunity?

How did Goodwin treat him poorly??

Robbed of games this year. All the best Luke.

Don't mind coach tearing stips off the players. Just hope someone is tearing strips of Goody for his absolute shambles of team selections in both finals. His selection blunders were just as worse as both losses.

Hear me out, if there was an opportunity to bring either onto our list next year as a player to then transition as a forwards development coach would you take up that opportunity? A Jack Riewoldt or Tom Hawkins would have been such a huge upgrade on Tom McDonald in both finals series. Tom Hawkins played 20 games and still kicked 49 goals this year. Remarkable effort. Jack Riewoldt played 21 games for 33 goals this year also. Could you imagine the leadership and development impact this would have on JVR, Petty and Jefferson?