joeboy

3- WJ

2- Scoop Junior

1- Jade

I'm not sure why you're comparing Rivers to Maguire. As far as talent, Rivers is head and shoulders above Maguire, big bodied or not big bodied!

Are you joking ?

Should we be targeting a player who is no improvement on our current CHB? Remember Jared Rivers?

I'd have thought we were all aware of Rivers' light frame and short stature being the only drawback to his being in the upper echelon of KPPs.

In terms of body structure Rivers is a boy compared to Maguire .

Maguire is big , strong , talented and dirty - EXACTLY what we need !

Yes and no. WJ and myself were bleating all week to play our untried players like garland and weetra and a couple of seniors could have played with Sandy. Sandy would then have at least made the prelim final. As far as the dees go as I also said if we had played my wife at Full forward and my Mother in law at CHF we would still have won. Carlton would not have lost even if we hadn't turned up. It was always going to be a Melbourne win. If we don't get Judd I hope the Blues do get him and that the costs in salary and the trade are horrendous for them. Remember the Eagles will want to trade Judd to a club where he can't hurt them in the finals and the Blues won't be there for years. if they sacrifice good players and high draft picks it will be harder for them especially if Judd's injury lingers. I can't see him going to Pies or Hawks. Blues if we fail are the club.

I don't think the comments about your wife are correct - from what I hear she has no left foot !

I would say that would apply to sources and "sauces" in general.

My source is on the Carlton Board .

The negotiations between Judd and The Glues have been going on for over 3 months according to my source.

A Carlton senior official told me today that I should put any money I had on the fact that Judd will be playing for his team next season .

I saw TJ last weekend with his arm in plaster .

3 - Whispy Jack - intelligent , articulate , diverse

2 - Scoop Junior - sensible , perceptive , forthright

1 - Jaded - logical , rational , objective .

Alright...

What your saying is;

Cameron Bruce's injury was a disappointment.

No him in general.

Right?

I hope you say yes...

Almost .

What I am saying is the effect of his being unable to contribute @ 100% capacity was " the major disappoinment "

It's not the MAJOR disapointment!!!!!

They were all hurt, they were all disapointing, he was not the one true MAJOR disapointment.

IMO as the premier player in the team ,his absence from the team through injury , or even when playing encumbered by injury , his lack of imput was the single 'major disappoinment ' in the year .

He also very humorously described how one of his sons was still a fervent Melbourne supporter and idolised Davey and Robertson , but warned him not to venture too close to them as they would be disappointments .

Bartram - excused , absent injured

Bate - second year blues

Bell - made gradual gains

Bizzell - retired too late

Brown - played to ability

Bruce - the major disappointment

Buckley - little to enthuse

Carroll - too much responsibility

Davey - a wasted year

Dunn - moments to savour

Ferguson - same old sameness

Frawley - injury curtailed development

Garland - the jury's out

Godfrey - handled tough assignments

Green - steady and reliable

Holland - some mercurial moments

Jamar - an underwhelming year

C. Johnson - may have expired

P. Johnson - not the answer

Johnstone - classy but detached

Jones - the shining light

McDonald - overworked and ageing

McLean - ruined early on

Miller - went nowhere quickly

Moloney - ruined by injury

Neitz - overworked and slowing

Neville - the jury's out

Newton - exciting but frustrating

Petterd - showed enough early

Pickett - a wasted year

Rivers - a major loss

Robertson - commendable despite injuries

Sylvia - never gained momentum

Ward - past his prime

Warnock - little to admire

Weetra - the jury's out

Wheatley - great when fit

Whelan - ruined by injury

White - totally one dimensional

Yze - past his prime

Bode - a late developer

Brown - going with glory

Carroll - year's worst game

Bizzell - fumbled and humbled

Ward - loose and disinterested

Johnstone - huge possession accumulator

McDonald - strangely ineffective game

Bate - very minor involvement

Pickett - classy but limited

Dunn - classy but spasmodic

Miller - effective in bursts

Bode - showed some glimpses

Bruce - playing out time

Green - classy when required

Robertson - heart and soul

Ferguson - brave but limited

C. Johnson - little to commend

P. Johnson - certainly no defender

Jamar - mistake- ridden performance

White - should have dominated

Newton - highs and lows

Jones - not at best

McLean - steady and dependable

Would like to know your 3 word comments from every player on the list for the season

I'll do it after the final round as always .

Like others previously , I also recall Brown's first agme against Carlton , when he saved the game with a sensational , and foolhardy full length dive and tackle which halted a forward thrust by the Blues with only seconds to go .

He always put the team ahead of his own safety and I would always marvel at his heroics .

Furthermore he has not overstayed his welcome and was probably our most consisitent performer over the last 4-6 weeks .

Putting a spanner in the works is last night's announcement that Melbourne has approached Dean Laidley's agent , thus ensuring that no announcement will be made until The Kangaroos' season is done and dusted .

6 - Green

5 - Brown

4 - McLean

3 - Robertson

2 - Pickett

1 - Jones

ok then buddy... first of all to say Mclean is losing leadership is utter crap! he had 23 possies and if u had watched the game u would have seen that he had to try and man up other opponents because half his teamates were lazy and [censored]! that is true leadership. And newton to be a major disappointment?? wtf! are u expecting to him to kick 5 goals every game. players take time. he has shown us all that he can play and will be a real talent in years to come. robbo playing out time? watever, the guy puts in 100% every game and tries his best. something i admire. and to say CJ chances have expied is why i think u didn't even watch the game. his disposal by foot and hand are lazer like. some that can actually hit a target! the rest i sorta agree but i reckon bode showed a bit. another who can hit a target.

On reflection I think I may have been over - critical of McLean , but he has set such a high level for himself that we ( I ) expect him to perform herculean efforts each week .

joeyboy- doesn't watch game

Ok smartarse what's your opinion of the players ?

Brown - continues to shine

Carroll - barber deserves conviction

Ferguson - devoid of strength

Ward - devoid of ability

Miller - devoid of passion

Green - only classy performer

Jones - quicker decisions needed

Dunn - needs settled position

Johnston - looking towards vacation

Pickett - loved his aggression

Buckley - has shown little

Bode - little to commend

C. Johnson - chances have expired

P. Johnson - lacks football understanding

Neitz - no captain's leadership

Bruce - diabolical foot disposal

Robertson - playing out time

Newton - major disappointment today

White - pointless ruck domination

Sylvia - played without purpose

McLean - fast losing captaincy

Jamar - nothing to commend

Brown - continued his reformation

Carroll - solid under fire

Holland - outstanding until injured

Bell - loose until injured

Ferguson - was surprisingly composed

Johnstone - played without passion

McDonald - inspired by occasion

Bate - disappointing yet again

Davey - continued poor season

Robertson - had little influence

Pickett - aggressive but unfit

Neitz - truly captain's game

Jamar - better second half

Sylvia - penny finally dropped

Dunn - some exciting moments

White - disappointed when needed

Jones - superlatives keep coming

Green - showed his class

Newton - showing his versatility

Wheatley - always under pressure

Bode - played his part

McLean - needed more involvement

Sylvinator:Always great posts

Yze Magic:Accurate predictions always

Finks: Another solid season

Queen C: Cool calm collected

Nasher:Astute assesments always

Rhino Richards: Absolute loose cannon

Jaded: Another seasoned pro

Jerry Lundergard:Words fail me

Rogue:his integrity guaranteed

Re draft Molan:Brilliant football mind

Joeboy:Needs thicker skin

I'm only asking for you to reveal the quality of your undoubtedly 'brilliant football mind ' for all the world to appreciate .

Don't make such flippant put downs without having the guts to give us all just a glimpse of how insightful you really are and how markedly different your opinions are to mine - but restrict yourself to 3 words .

What game were you watching again!

Hey , sorry to give you such an incorrect analysis , but I'd really love to read your 3 words , because I hear you have such a brilliant football mind .

Please feel free to share your wisdom here .