Gator

The omnipresent Windsor.

Unfortunately, I won't be there. As for Jefferson ? He has no presence or urgency. I'll be mildly shocked if he makes it at AFL level. Some players scream ''I'm the man''. I wasn't keen on young Caddy in his final junior year, because he dropped sitters and looked fumbly, but he did have aggression in spades. Even at just 19 he thinks he's the man at AFL level. At age 17 Jesse Hogan playing for Casey knew he was the man. Jefferson is the opposite of ''I'm the man''. That's OK if you can still attack the contest like your life depended on it. I see that with van Rooyen, I don't with Jefferson. Someone else said he'll never be a pack crasher. If you're key position size at AFL level there's a level of competing in packs that's a non-negotiable for a forward. I don't think he has that level. Sorry to hurt people's feelings.

Do some supporters think if it isn't spoken about it might go away ? That's hysterical. Nothing has changed. It will be discussed in the media most days for the rest of the year. The MFC will do what is best for the MFC. I wouldn't trade him under any circumstances at the end of this year. The end of 2026 you'd have to consider it.

Just fleetingly. In the sessions I've been to Langdon has lined up on the wing, half-forward and in the middle. At a guess, 80% of the time he's been in the middle. And looked great.

Ruckman often say stupid things.

But only 4 players could be interchanged at any one time. So players in the 30 had to be subbed on or out of the game.

You're basing his career on Demonland posters ?

Culley isn't as far away as some think. It's a long season and Culley is perfect if there's an injury to one of the bigger bodied mids, or players need a rest. It might be Langford, or they may look to rest Viney, Petracca, Rivers, or Oliver later in the year.

I'll be amazed if Rivers plays defence. He's played every minute as a mid and has thrived in this role. With Windsor, Salem, Howes, Hore, and Bowey, the defence is covered. Lindsay played a lot of half-back as a junior, so it's not beyond the pale for him to go back if needed. The last thing I'd be doing is sending Rivers back when he's looked great through the middle during preseason.

Campbell rucked against Xerri and the 193cm Johnson rucked against skinny kids.

That team is missing 9 of our starting 18, including some all-time greats of the MFC, and it's still better than some Melbourne teams I've seen run around this century.

It's very impressive that you didn't say ''chomping''.

I highly doubt that May, Lever, Petty and McDonald will all play against a Giants side that loves its small pressure forwards. At Casey, during one of the intraclubs, it was Howes who went to Pickett late in the game when he went to full forward. There may not be a huge difference in height between Howes and McDonald, and yes, Harley Reid made Howes look silly, but I'll be very surprised if Howes doesn't line up in round 1. I'll be just as surprised if McDonald does. Btw, McDonald has been good in the sessions I've attended, but the balance just doesn't work.

Can you quote back to me the part where I'm "staunchly committed to defending a player that we haven't even signed yet". Thanks.