Jibroni

Why cant Geelong just go away and die.

Would love nothing more than to win this but I just dont see it.

The problem what maybe "derogatory" for one person is not for another, particularly in this instance where the player receiving the remark was not offended. If the player was a homosexual footballer naturally this would be a different discussion. I thought a one match ban for a first offence would be fair (with a probation/education added) and any further offence incurring a harsher penalty (ie: 5 weeks). And yes I would feel the same if a MFC player was involved.

I think when you have an organisation like the AFL trying to act as the moral arbitrator for society we have a problem. Rankine made a mistake, nothing more.

Whatever results helps Collingwood miss the 8 and Geelong Top 4

This is the AFL, they have no integrity.

Nothing against Newcombe but I think the AFL will find a way to get him off.

I believe this is the right decision but as usual the club has managed this pretty ordinary. This decision either should have been done after the St Kilda game or let him coach out the season. Goodwin delivered a premiership and some moments which will never be forgotten. I wish him well.

Outside of addressing the online post; that is a pretty toothless response when some serious action is needed.

As much as losing like this really socks, surely this result will start the ball rolling in some coaching/staff changes.

What's Nathan Buckley's ph number?

At 28 and based on his body of work this season I would not be making a massive offer (give up a first wound selection) if I was a rival club.

Tipping the Dogs as my upset for the weekend.

My Demonitis has a bad feeling about today.

State of Origin was great in the 80/90s but it's has lost its cache.

I dont know if the AFL comes up with these ideas themselves or pay consultants to come up ideas that a five year old could devise. I’d prefer that my team sell a home game to Antartica than participate in whatever they come up with.

Would have him back tomorrow, he is a great operator and we need his skillset to return.

Bergman would be a walk up start but otherwise yes we had more than enough talent to win this game.

Option 3 would destroy the aesthetics of the game, just look at VAR in Football/Soccer. If you watch state league football you will notice the depth in umpiring does not exist and the AFL does seem to want to invest the millions required due to other priorities (whatever they happen to be). I would agree returning to 3 umpires and simplifying some interpretations (ie: Deliberate. HTB) would be the best move forward.

We lost because we cannot convert I50, a problem that has been ongoing for the last 3 years. Umpiring was average but this is not on them.

I was at the game and was surprised to see as many St Kilda supporters as dees fans, particularly when it came to merchandise sales too. It seems that after 10 years we have made minimal community impact which is really disappointing. I think it's time to find a new location (country Victoria) or as members pay a little extra.

Value for money he is one of the best trades the club has pulled off.

I think the Big Lady entered when Brisbane ran through there banner, lol.

Please tell me this is not fake news???

Unless Brayshaw or Serong have a sudden burning desire to leave Fremantle then its a simple no. Love Jacko but if he does want to return to the Dees, this can be done via a separate trade.