DistrACTION Jackson

My god, Sumich is so full of excrement it's mind blowing how these people have jobs in the media. 18 year old key forward plays in reserves to improve football ability rather than getting thrown to the wolves..... Then imagine we did play him last year, would just say oh the mishandling of van Rooyen for playing him too early....

Connor O'Sullivan looks pretty impressive, if we decide to take two top 10 picks instead. He looks almost a carbon copy of Darcy Moore. Imagine pairing him up with Petty for 10 years.

Totally agree.... but just preparing everyone in the event it does happen.

The issue is I have heard rumours that the AFL plan to give North a band 1 compo for losing McKay and may also give them academy access to Sanders. If this happens, North will likely be taking Watson, McKercher and Sanders.

Yeah I agree with that, there is unfortunately not many key forwards available.

The thing I wonder with Georgiades is he isn't a big key forward, he's more a medium forward. I think we need a bit 196/197cm strong key forward in the Hawkins, Mitch Lewis, Larkey mould.

I love people saying, oh but he has the best list. How can anyone actually quantify the 'best list'. I guess you could take the player ratings and then work out the average across each list, but that is skewed because some players haven't played as many games in the most recent history which is what that is calculated by. It's a complete furphy we have the best list. We have a great backline and midfield, but our forwardline would be nowhere near the best on raw talent.

It's a hard one for Brown. He's probably our smartest forward with his leading patterns, other than maybe Fritsch. But watching him you can just tell he is really struggling with movement. Is it better to play Petty forward, who doesn't have as good craft but is more mobile and better when the ball hits the deck.

I was thinking they are a good chance to beat Port, but losing Rankine late and still having Rachele out is a huge loss. Rankine was easily their best player yesterday.

If we do have the option to trade for Gold Coasts first pick, I think I would rather take pick 4/5 and pick 6/7 to the draft and get two top 10 picks. Could give us the chance to draft a Durrsma/Watson combo or something like that. You would have to assume that the fact Duursma is playing games at Casey we must have some interest.

If they want to have a wildcard weekend I don't really care either way, no one from 7-10 is winning a flag let's be honest. If it creates more money and interest in the AFL then I guess it's good overall for the game. In regards to the 17-6 fixture, I would hate if they play 17 games and then break into teams of 6 and only play off against those sides for spots. That is just a stupid idea and would disadvantage teams who maybe started slowly and are firing late, as say you are 7th by % then that is a huge price to pay with 6 games left. What I would like to see is the first 17 games every team plays and then there is a bye week as the AFL works out the fixture for the remaining 6 games. Teams can then be given a weighted draw based on difficulty to ensure each team has a relatively similar draw. This bye weekend would also then coincide with the opening round of the AFLW fixture, so that there is still football on and then the women's competition will run from there and continue after the men's finals are finished.

The upside to this is Tommo will be playing for his career in a way, given the way he performs this week may go a long way to another side offering a trade

The team on top literally play 2 rucks....

Or the alternative is every side plays two of the top 6, middle 6 and bottom 6. Keeps the fixture as even as possible.

Good stuff from Goody calling out the media. One thing we have to remember is that McInerney has had to carry a huge load this year and Maxy has had to do a lot less than previous seasons. This would have to be a factor in how he performed on the weekend and this is only going to be a larger factor into finals. Both Gawn and Grundy will be as fresh as they probably ever have for a finals series.

I floated the idea of a 17-6 fixture on here a few months ago..... the CEOs are on Dland.

We can easily look at other FAs to cover him if he leaves, Matt Crouch and Paddy Dow come to mind as similar players. Let's not forget we will be bringing in at a minimum a top 10 pick this year, potentially 2 if we trade with GC.

I'd like to see the club come out and say 'Grundy is in our plans both this season and into the future and we will not be entertaining any trades' just to get the media to stfu. I genuienly despise the AFL media these days, it has become an absolute cesspool.

The carry on is quite amazing

He is definitely a butcher. Turns it over time and time again, but the media seem to love him.

How about we just have an 18 team finals and hand out participation awards. Seriously there is no reason to do this other than to have more games for the sake of it. Maybe the AFL should focus on a fairer fixture rather than spending time talking about wildcard rounds. Absolute peanuts.

Whether it works or not is yet to be seen, but the media are acting like we think Grundy will suddenly become Tom Hawkins and win a coleman. The club obviously just want him to slightly improve his forward craft, so he can do an adequate job down there and then take relief ruck for the remainder of the season. There is absolutely no reason he can't learn the basic running patterns etc. and then create a contest, which is essentially what JVR is doing right now as a forward in his infancy. Grundy is an intelligent person, so one would think he can pick up the basic requirements pretty easily.

I was actually impressed by his kicking inside 50. Laced out three passes, two resulting with shots on goal and the other Caddy dropped an absolute sitter with no pressure and literally hit him on the chest. He will take a couple of seasons to get an AFL body, but can see him replacing Hunter quite easily in a wing role.

I really don't get the big deal about a side choosing to send a player back to VFL to work on some things, plus also get a bit of a rest after coming off a 12 month injury.

Tbf to the Pies they lost by 6 points to the premier and 1 point in the prelim, so we can't question their ability to perform on the biggest stage. Sometimes results don't go your way, which was interesting because they won every close game in the regular season from memory. I just think they showed they can continue to perform into the finals, though past history isn't a guarantee of future performance as all investment ads tell us.... Port on the other hand have a history of choking in finals, the best example being one of the most insipid performances in recent memory against the Dogs in 2021. But again, thinking history will just repeat is too simplistic a view.