Sarcasm alert 

while the usual vfl suspects flourished: Bill Laurie, JVR, Riv, Dunstan, Chandler, Hunt, Melky, Weid and even everyones favourite prospective project ruckman Bell was good. Rosman, DSMith and McVee didn't really impact with ball in hand, i know its geelong in geelong but she's gotta be close to writing on the wall almost

9 hours ago, Turner said:

while the usual vfl suspects flourished: Bill Laurie, JVR, Riv, Dunstan, Chandler, Hunt, Melky, Weid and even everyones favourite prospective project ruckman Bell was good. Rosman, DSMith and McVee didn't really impact with ball in hand, i know its geelong in geelong but she's gotta be close to writing on the wall almost

A measured response, Turner, well done! D Smith was unfortunate to be poleaxed, and probably concussed, late in the game. Rosman finding it difficult to have an impact in recent games.

14 hours ago, Turner said:

while the usual vfl suspects flourished: Bill Laurie, JVR, Riv, Dunstan, Chandler, Hunt, Melky, Weid and even everyones favourite prospective project ruckman Bell was good. Rosman, DSMith and McVee didn't really impact with ball in hand, i know its geelong in geelong but she's gotta be close to writing on the wall almost

Agree with all that but Rosman has the most upside if he does get better.   He's tall, solid build, can jump over a pack to mark,  is an elite runner, and kicks the ball further and faster than most.  The trouble is he doesn't do anywhere near enough of that in a game.   I saw him pre season and thought how good is this guy going to be.  Don't know what the answer is.

On 7/9/2022 at 2:23 PM, stinga said:

Agree with all that but Rosman has the most upside if he does get better.   He's tall, solid build, can jump over a pack to mark,  is an elite runner, and kicks the ball further and faster than most.  The trouble is he doesn't do anywhere near enough of that in a game.   I saw him pre season and thought how good is this guy going to be.  Don't know what the answer is.

It's not true to say he has a solid build - he doesn't, and he certainly doesn't play at his weight or build, he plays below it and is regularly pushed off it by harder smaller opponents.  He's destined to be delisted.