18 minutes ago, Skuit said:

You're right P-Man. Two games doesn't tell us anything. Watching almost his entire career and the fact that he can't make the depleted Port team-sheet however tells us that he wouldn't be a massive upgrade on the likes of JKH as contended - who, if I recall correctly, had a crazy patch of state-level form leading up to those two matches.

We all saw what happened to Trenners. He lost his pace, and he didn't have much penetration on his kick to begin with. Without any elite skills, he doesn't now have the physical attributes to successfully step up to the next level. It's the same case with JKH I'm afraid.

Love Trenners and miss him, and would love to have his services the last few weeks, but we don't

JKH is depth for our best 22, but I think he's good depth, he's faster than Trenners and fitter than many others and gives 110% including laying more than his fair share of Tackles. And there's potential upside IMHO

I'm not resigning his fortunes to the scrap heap yet, just wishing he was getting the chance to impact when we need his depth rather than being out injured when his opportunity is here

4 hours ago, Graeme Yeats' Mullet said:

Love Trenners and miss him, and would love to have his services the last few weeks, but we don't

JKH is depth for our best 22, but I think he's good depth, he's faster than Trenners and fitter than many others and gives 110% including laying more than his fair share of Tackles. And there's potential upside IMHO

I'm not resigning his fortunes to the scrap heap yet, just wishing he was getting the chance to impact when we need his depth rather than being out injured when his opportunity is here

Sorry but I disagree with your assessment. JKH is pedestrian & o's like a deer in headlights. Has been a list clogger & unless he finds his niche position asap then he's goneski

with his fitness, jkh would've been handy to start the season

wishing him luck as the season plays but, sadly, like trenners i don't think he's good enough for afl

2 hours ago, samcantstandya said:

Sorry but I disagree with your assessment. JKH is pedestrian & o's like a deer in headlights. Has been a list clogger & unless he finds his niche position asap then he's goneski

JKH has been unlucky.
Been playing his best footy for us before getting injured.

4 hours ago, Fork 'em said:

JKH has been unlucky.
Been playing his best footy for us before getting injured.

Would have been close to playing round 1 had it not be for his injury.