Just for those posters that think ,if Viney go to GWS or GC that he will return to us in two years time because of the "Go home" factor

We have 19 players on our list/rookie list who have come from interstate

5 from SA

4 from Qld

6 from WA

3 from Tas

1 from NT

I think, from memory, 1 went home because he wanted to...(S.Thompson)

A couple of others went because they were no longer requied....

All young players get homesick, but the clubs are very good now at intergrating them into their system and very few good players now want to change clubs because they want to go 'home' Judd comes to mind.....There are always rumours that "Oh he wants to go home" but it occurs very rarely now.

So if your thinking that we can lose Viney and that he will come back......Forget it.

Just for those posters that think ,if Viney go to GWS or GC that he will return to us in two years time because of the "Go home" factor

We have 19 players on our list/rookie list who have come from interstate

5 from SA

4 from Qld

6 from WA

3 from Tas

1 from NT

I think, from memory, 1 went home because he wanted to...(S.Thompson)

A couple of others went because they were no longer requied....

All young players get homesick, but the clubs are very good now at intergrating them into their system and very few good players now want to change clubs because they want to go 'home' Judd comes to mind.....There are always rumours that "Oh he wants to go home" but it occurs very rarely now.

So if your thinking that we can lose Viney and that he will come back......Forget it.

zzzzzzzzz not another viney thread....seriously?

zzzzzzzzz not another viney thread....seriously?

This coming from you?

Let's hear a trade scenario that will never occur.

Edited August 10, 201213 yr by rpfc

Not a Viney Thread....A going home myth..

This coming from you?

Let's hear a trade scenario that will never occur.

*Crickets*

This coming from you?

Let's hear a trade scenario that will never occur.

or lets trade tapscott for caddy ;-)

This coming from you?

Let's hear a trade scenario that will never occur.

Gysberts for Motlop

This coming from you?

Let's hear a trade scenario that will never occur.

Its all about playing to percentage. If a recruiter doesn't suggest it then there is 0% chance of it occurring.

If a recruiter does suggest it then there is a minimum of 0.0001% chance of it occurring. Got to be in it to Win it i says!~!