Trading our First two Picks for Beams & Wellingham

[stuie 7,374]

This reply about Dunn gave me a chuckle.

He is AA but I honestly think that our recruiting resources should focus on what we need, and thats Mids Mids and maybe a link up player.

I really do not think its worth the effort having meetings and trying to negotiate for out of contract defenders. Our defense is fine, especially now with young Tom Mac

Agree that mids are our most pressing need, but it doesn't mean we can't improve other areas too... I'm sure we can get more than one trade done if we need to

[Deestroy All 14,262]

Really? That's our criteria is it?

Great player, wouldn't want to pay overs for him, but it'd free up Garland to stay forward which might be an option if there's no go with Cloke.

People are a bit too wishful with the trades they're expecting and far too dismissive of what we are actually capable of getting.

He is far from a great player.

He doesn't defend for a start.

And his kick it long to nothing style would fit right in with us. I'd rather see less of that, not more.

Another example of a Collingwood player being overrated, because he plays for Collingwood.

There's a reason knowledgeable Pies fans would rather O'brien be squeazed out before anyone else.

[Ouch! 2,258]

Just as a side issue.... anyone see the irony of a player like Harry O'Brien leaving to go to another club because of money? with his selfless, non-materialistic lifestyle?

I can't see it happening, the Pies are gonna be stuck with him until they force him out

[stuie 7,374]

Another example of a Collingwood player being overrated, because he plays for Collingwood.

And is a premiership player and an all-australian...

[Dee1987 277]

Would love Harry O'brien at the Dees love his dash of Half Back, would enable Grimes to Play more in the middle. Not sure whats happening with the Cloke saga if he definatley did not want to come to us he would of signed, i reckon they thinking hard about 6-7 year deal.

[CRomey 36]

Beams has been at a club that has the money and therefore coaching staff and facilities etc. to develop young players quite well, something Melbourne hasn't been doing too well. The fact that he has already been developed by a club like Collingwood makes him much more valuable. He's only 22 and would be a perfect addition to our midfield. To be perfectly honest I would much rather pay the money for him than Cloke at the moment. With Beams and Viney teaming up in the middle along with other's like Trengove, Jones and even Grimes and McKenzie, we would have an extremely bright looking midfield. But of course Beams is going to be one of the last players Collingwood would let go, Eddie will start trying to declare war on us and we'll never hear the end of it.

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

Would love Harry O'brien at the Dees love his dash of Half Back, would enable Grimes to Play more in the middle. Not sure whats happening with the Cloke saga if he definatley did not want to come to us he would of signed, i reckon they thinking hard about 6-7 year deal.

the way we are going Harry O would be too busy defending and not running off half back. FWIW when he has to defend I don't think he does a great job.

[cowboy_from_hell 2,390]

With beams signing or close to it with pies how the hell are they going to get cloke to his 7-9 hundred thousand a year?

[jurrahcane 70]

This post in a dead end. Cloke, Beams & Wellingham will be in black and white in 2013