Was overtaken by Jamar as the No. 1 ruckman and only played eight games for the season. Has been in and out of the team and with others often preferred as a second ruckman, his position is on the line - Luke Holmesby melbournefc

Games MFC 2010 8 Career 69 Goals MFC 2010 3 Career 20

Games CSFC 2010 10 Goals CSFC 2010 2

Games MFC 2010 8 Career 69 Goals MFC 2010 3 Career 20

Games CSFC 2010 10 Goals CSFC 2010 2

That about covers it, IMO he will only survive if Spencer gets the chop.

It will I think come down to which one we keep while waiting for Gawn and Fitz to mature.

can see him staying another year...with macca, bell and miller gone...we might get rid of a few more like maric, cheeney and mcnamara...

prefer to 'carry' spare big blokes than the likes of maric, cheeney and mcnamara...

we will keep jordie and spencer...

What to say?

I'll be annoyed if he isn't delisted.

Paul will sign a new deal before he goes with the team to China to play the Lions

What to say?

I'll be annoyed if he isn't delisted.

if jamar goes down with an injury and pj is gone...we are pretty exposed...spencer can't ruck by himself at the moment...and steph martin is struggling with form...gawn is years away...fitzpatrick is much the same...

PJ is in the same boat as the other blokes you have named that are not up to it.

The difference is that PJ is older and has had his chance.

I also happen to know that he himself remains uncertain of whether he'll be offered a new contract.

How I know, I won't go into.

Unfortunately he is the classic example of a list clogger.

Writing > wall

What to say?

I'll be annoyed if he isn't delisted.

I hope we keep him-just look what has happened with the Russian.I sincerely hope he replicates what he has done.