Scully had 10 turnovers. He was clean with his hands and worked really hard but wasn't BOG due to his turnovers. Really needs to cut that 40 meter lob pass to a pack out of his game...

If Scully wasn't the BOG then I'm not a Demons Fan.

I read all the papers, watched all the reports, saw his game with my own eyes.

Not BOG? You must be kidding.

The term "Country Mile" even comes to mind.

When it comes to Brownlow Votes even Friday nights umpires will get it right.

If Scully wasn't the BOG then I'm not a Demons Fan.

I read all the papers, watched all the reports, saw his game with my own eyes.

Not BOG? You must be kidding.

The term "Country Mile" even comes to mind.

When it comes to Brownlow Votes even Friday nights umpires will get it right.

Giansircusa will get the 3 in the winning side. I'm not denying he was great but 10 turnovers is pretty ugly. Sorry to be the bearer of bad news...

Giansircusa will get the 3 in the winning side. I'm not denying he was great but 10 turnovers is pretty ugly. Sorry to be the bearer of bad news...

When the result is tight it is quite possible that the best player in the losing side could be given 3 votes. Scully could be in line for 3 votes.

Your nit picking of his performance in the conditions completely ignores his impact on the game.

Giansircusa will get the 3 in the winning side. I'm not denying he was great but 10 turnovers is pretty ugly. Sorry to be the bearer of bad news...

well..The Age for one had him as the best on ground

footballer of the year

Giansiracusa didnt get a look in !!

team of the week rnd 7

Matt Burgan has Scully starting in the middle.. and Giansiracusa on the bench.

seems to be a pattern here

Edited May 10, 201015 yr by belzebub59

Both coaches gave Scully best on ground.

And Grimes got 4 votes for equal third best on ground, well well well! How ill-disciplined he must have been.

Both coaches gave Scully best on ground.

And Grimes got 4 votes for equal third best on ground, well well well! How ill-disciplined he must have been.

Wasteful too.

But geez I love him. General written all over him.

Everyone is bagging Grimes' disposal and decision making. Firstly yes he did make mistakes i grant you that but you would be ignorant not to think the weather played a factor. I have never seen so many dropped marks (esp chest marks), out on the fulls and turnovers in a match, and you have to remember we were playing the highly skillful WB. Plus Grimes's ball use and decision making has been superb all year. So do not judge to quickly, he will probs destroy WC.