He is also a W.A Boy through & through, so would have only stayed with us for 2-3 years (scott Thompson re-visited)

I don't believe this.

This thread is worth a life ban

YES !!!!!! Relax people ONE GAME IN !!!!

I don't believe this.

I watched many WAFL Games last year. He was never going to leave the state i assure you.

YES !!!!!! Relax people ONE GAME IN !!!!

So would anyone have any objections to me closing it?

I mean seriously are we really going to debate the worth of two talented youngsters after their first games........

He was never going to leave the state i assure you.

I don't believe this.

I don't believe this.

And we are never, ever going to know, so who really cares?

I don't believe this.

Believe what you like, but after what happened with Thompson, where we got Burnt. The Fact that Jack was a victorian boy played a big part. As both Rich & Natinui are far more advanced.

He's so 'WA though and through' that he was born in Fiji and grew up in Sydney.

I doubt that the 'go home' factor was a very large one with Naitanui.

This is directed to the wrong person.

Maybe but the point still stands.......

So would anyone have any objections to me closing it?

I mean seriously are we really going to debate the worth of two talented youngsters after their first games........

[/quote

I am all for closing it.

Maybe but the point still stands.......

It was a needless point to make.

Are you female ?

It was a needless point to make.

Are you female ?

And on that attempt at an insult (watch yourself H), this thread is now closed.