Willmoy1947

And he wasn't on the bloody field either

Yep fair question. I think I meant I would be concerned about the effect on the team harmony with any quality player leaving unless it was done as last course of action to take.

That could do more damage to the Club than letting him go

Not for the first WC seem to think it's to their advantage to water the ground.As well, the worst and most dangerous exhibition of maggotisms for the the year Lots of high stuff let go as well every experienced WC (suitable) player thought it was his job to knuckle another player..

Does the AFL actually pay people to make decisions on replay moments of inconclusive goals? I could have sworn I saw the ball trajectory change and I'm partially 20/20.. yet it was a goal.

Carltons cap always amazes..

Depends on whose side they are on.

I thought that had happened already.

Look at Carltonpoo as well..

Players are trained to be dobbers??

Bloody Republicans

And he is smart enough to realise that as well.

I do think Umpires have an ongoing responsibility to protect the upper part of the body including the head and neck, just like rugby purportes to be doing, and probably isn't. A few folk on this site like to have a different perspective on things and that's ok, but there is no longer an argument that the Earth is flat either.

Umpiring is an inconclusive science based on negligible human error, or the fraternity would like to think so...

Well I don't agree. I'm not only referring to our games but all games. There are a host of retribution frees and frees done on whims and think it happened frees every week. Footscray get a myriad of frees winning or losing.

Just one small point it's not the number, it's when they are given, it's the consistency from week to week and rule emphasis to rule obscurity.

Yes, your right but as we both think he is really a great cognitive awareness player for us.Captain material, yes and there are others. At a recent interview one could see his insightful perspectives.Really we don't want to lose a player and club potential career member for the foreseeable future with this chap. Modern,savvy, well presented and very well spoken.

Where he bloody well likes..

Don't risk him.

Not for me. they both go missing sometimes and that is natural and depends on a lot of different thing. They both kick goals on different days. Macca had to play his 200 in the ones and was suitably rewarded., and deserved it. Why wont weid replace Macca in a couple of weeks if needed? Not over by a long stretch.

Couple of mentions, Bowie congrats on the record and a really big boost to Jordan and Sparrow for just a tough, never take a short step approach and great support for a centre line that goes those extra yards. They have cemented their spots.

What a pathetic bunch of umpires in the Ad/ Car game. Terribly soft decisions holding ball, pathetic attempts to even up once ball moves to backline Talk about momentum moments Eddy Betts was on to it. Give us a changing of the guard with commentators prepared to speak their mind. Silvanghi always manages to fall over behind the play.Is because he is awkward or such a good player or dirty.

I'm trying to remember the last time I saw Cripps handball

Why didn't you tell em you were going to go around to their flats and burn them all down.😇

I must admit I was worried for first25 seconds