Cranky Franky

And yet he played AFL this year - for a much better team. At the time we preferred Oscar McD & Tomlinson to him. Evidence of another List management FAIL.

Dunstan, Billings & now Steele. Good grief

And Oskar Baker & Frost were getting games this year in better teams than ours.

It irks me to agree with Demonstone but Harmes was solid that day & nowhere near a blinder or in the best players.

Easy old son. Have some hot milk maybe an anti depressant & chill out.

Apart from a few games Viney doesn't cut it in the middle any more.

Just hold you marks !!!

His days as a starting midfielder are over. Needs to find a new role if he wants to remain relevant - hard tagger maybe.

I've saw about 8 Casey games. A more accurate assessment would be "I'm hopeful that Luker & Jeffo will develop into regular AFL players". Super excited is definitely hubris.

Anyone who gets "super excited" about our young key forwards who got pantsed by Frankston's country footballers probably has a low excitement threshold.

Unless he can sort out his injuries his days as an elite player are over.

I reckon you should set up a GoFundMe page for poor old put upon Judd and help him with his removal costs to WA. Or maybe you can be President of Judd's new fan club.

Tim was delusional when he said the Club had done well in its player trading in the last few years. Recent player trading has been woeful and taken the Club backwards big time.

The way he was managed this year was a disgrace. Came into the firsts without any fitness or form to warrant selection. Club completely stuffed his year.

Must improve his disposal by hand & foot if he wants to stay relevant in the modern game.

Put him back on a wing & leave him there.

Waiting for a breakout game from Blake.

Has talent but was poorly managed this year. Was struggling mid year & should have been sent to Casey to work on a few things.

Well maybe you can start a Judd McVee Fan club & be President or maybe a gofundme page for him to defray his removal costs.

Agree That's BS. He wouldn't make any of the top 8 sides on this year's form. Rankine tore him a new one. And he cost us the final in 2023 in the last minute. Jumped to spoil, missed everything & left Docherty to kick a goal. Absolutely dumb play.

Where are Demonland standards - some posters would get suspended for the above comments.

Very well put. Apart from 3 or 4 games Judd was mostly poor & rarely attacked or took a risk. Should have been dropped. Cost us the Port game when Rankine cut him to pieces. Good riddance.

One of Goodies biggest blunders was not using him as a mid this year.

Our selection of young developing ruckmen in the last 10 years or so has been dreadful surely the worst in the AFL. And our trading for experienced back ups (Schache, Fullerton) has been even worse.

Go and do some boxing & wrestling training. Needs to get more aggressive & physical.