Random Task

Rumours of discontent?

I'm just a fan that wants their young kids to do well and not [censored] on them as an easy scapegoat. I already said he needs to improve or he'll be off the list come the end of the year. I've watched plenty of his games last year and including the Carlton game. There's enough to work with for him to make it at afl level in my view but he's certainly up against it. You don't rate him at all and thats fine, let's leave it at that.

I interpreted that he was doing rehab with the club, just away from the main training group at goschs/Casey...

He won't be a free agent, we'll have to trade for him.

Unpopular opinion on here it seems but I hope they persist with Laurie, at least for a few more games. Kid has skill, is one of our best by hands and when he gets his confidence up he should sharpen up those kicking skills and help our delivery inside forward 50. In my view he appears to be a confidence player and doesn't believe he belongs yet. Doesn't help when langdon runs across his kicking line, smothering the kick and then scolds him for it, nor would it help when he was clearly ignored by Salem while he was 20 metres in the clear inside 50. Out of the 6 games he's played he's been sub or subbed out 5 times. He will want to start showing some serious improvement however and I don't think a forward line can include all of Him, Chandler, Anb, Pickett and Spargo with McAdam to come. Up to him to start taking these chances otherwise he'll be in strife come the end of the year.

Thanks, I mainly use the app but do jump on a desktop from time to time... no idea how I missed that.

Still no membership numbers? Information from the club app and websites gets stripped back more and more each year.

I've seen plenty from him that warrants further investment. Not saying he'll definitely make it but I wouldn't be putting a line through his name after one season.

Afl website ladder paints a different story, though I'm not sure it makes sense.

Not sure why some people are eager to write off a young key forward that hasn't even started his second year. Club was impressed enough with his first year to extend his stay until 2026, if he's not playing regularly by then I'll start to be concerned.

Collingwood 15 entries for 0 goals... relatable

Collingwood losing...

It's not even round 1 and we have some articles highlighting rival club interest in players and potential FA moves. While not everyone's cup of tea, particularly when the seasons barely begun, I'll always be interested in the player movement space and the possibilities out there to improve our list. This article can kick us off, with alleged strong interest in swans RFA Will Hayward from "multiple clubs" and the Hawks supposedly entering the race for JUH. https://www.foxsports.com.au/afl/afl-trade-news-2024-interest-in-will-hayward-hawks-chasing-jamarra-uglehagan-sydney-swans-western-bulldogs-hawthorn-hawks-out-of-contract-free-agent-news-rumours-whispers/news-story/920412d4cee9dd33d20c6df0ce55862b

Indeed. But they didn't have that in 2021 when they finished 17th. They also traded away the rights to Finn Callaghan after moving on their first round pick the year before. That would have caused an absolute meltdown here. Things can change quickly if you have a good system and star players to work around. Can we sort our system out? Time will tell.

At least we won't finish on the bottom of the ladder this week.

Bowser out for approx 8 weeks as per mfc site.

Agreed. Can't see us acquiring an established key forward star as much as we'd like one. At the end of the year we are likely to have significant cash with Brayshaw, B Brown, T-Mac, Melksham with ? Over J Smith, Hunter, Tomlinson (likely to stay on given our key position depth issues?) and Laurie. Add in expanded cap space and we should have well over $1mil. That's not including a potential trade request from Petty or any other surprise contracted player along the way. However, given the evident holes on the list we should really go about acquiring multiple established mid tier players to compliment our stars. McRae shipped out Grundy to facilitate the influx of Bobby Hill, McStay, Tom Mitchell and Frampton. That won them the flag the following year. We, hopefully without losing a core 22 player, need to utilise our cap to attack the trade and FA period in a similar fashion. In no particular order we need a Ruck, Mid, Medium defender, Key Forward as well as potentially insurance for life after May.

Yes but would be surprised if he got opportunities this year. Drafted in the same year as Jeffo so still has lot of development to go in both his game and his body.

Anyone know if the VFL practice match has been played already and possibly details about best players etc..

In: Pickett, Woewodin, Fullarton Out: Bowey, Laurie, Schache Few half forwards lucky we don't have a lot of depth ready to come in.

6. May 5. Viney 4. Tomlinson 3. McVee 2. Fritsch 1. Howes

Was good to see Windsor and Howes. Not sure I can compliment much else except for May's performance for 3 and 1/2 quarters. Hope Boweys injury isn't serious. Still baffles me that such a strong contest/defence team can be so poor in "wet weather" conditions.

Laurie should be in the 22 over Chandler based on their pre-season performance. Would also prefer to have a strong aerobic athlete playing from the start and have an impact player come on later in the game.

Haven't really seen a prediction thread so I thought I would throw a few darts at the wall without too much thought. 1. Brisbane 2. Melbourne 3. Collingwood 4. GWS 5. Carlton 6. Port 7. Bulldogs 8. Adelaide 9. Freo 10. Sydney 11. St Kilda 12. Gold Coast 13. Geelong 14. Kangaroos 15. Essendon 16. Richmond 17. Hawks 18. West Coast Premiers: Melbourne (biased of course) Runners up: GWS Wooden Spoon: Eagles Brownlow: Daicos Rising Star: Sanders Melbourne BnF: Petracca Freo and Sydney are two I'm unsure about. Can see a world where they're both in the 8 but equally I wouldn't be surprised to see them fall further than I have them here.