Moonshadow

Saints now have all the players who nominated them. Good effort

Officially a Saint now.

Absolutely. That's why we shouldn't trade for GWS future 1st rounder

No, it's Keeff.

Carlton could include a future pick in the Papley deal. I'd rather Weightman at 8 than Papley. Papley would cost too much, both in terms of pick and contract. Desperately clutching at straws to combine goal assist stats and goals kicked to rate him. Fools gold.

Martin (like Keith) can go into the national draft, as opposed to PSD, with terms set for price and years. Any club with a pick willing to meet those terms can take him. Luke Ball did that, Saints got 0.

True, but his terms could be met by a number of clubs in the national draft. Bit of a gamble really.

Yes, but Ball went to Pies in the draft. We are talking about Keith going to the preseason draft. Would've thought the Dogs would do the honourable thing and trade for him.

I resemble that.

Big deal. Off you go to your Richmond forum, Tugger.

Pick 3 for 6 + Caldwell or O'Halloran NOT 3 for 6 + 2020 1st rounder GWS want pick 3 and Green with late trash picks, then cough the [censored] up! Otherwise it's Green at 6 only. Play hard Dees.

So you think Smith will still be just as quick and far nearing 33 years of age? Good for you. Lewis was far from a trash and treasure pick up IMO. I'd be fine for us to have Smith, but only costing very little and for 1 year with tough incentives for 2. I think he's 12 mths off done

Sounds like one of those happy-go-luckies to me, Binny!

Yes, we won the equivalent of pick 50. Yay!

GWS first round pick next year may be 25 or even higher after a raft of academy pick are matched

GWS 1st rounder next year may well be in the late 20s after all the bidding is matched. We should think of the pick number rather than 1st or 2nd round I'd rather 3 for 6 + Caldwell or O'Halloran. If GWS really want 3 and Green they need to give something more than 6 and 2020's pick 25ish

Of course it is. What did you expect during the off season, a bombshell announcement? If Oscar can get more strength in his body over summer and be able to hold his own in the contest, I think he might surprise a few next year. Not a star, but has a role to play and needs to step up.

Bad trade call. Number 2 stinks.

Only pick Green with 3 if he's worth pick 3. They may let him pass, with the knowledge that the rank of available draftees moves up a spot. However, if they do match a bid at 3 they'll use up pick 6, which means 8 moves up a spot.

They won't trade next year's 1st as they'll need it for academy points, plus pick 10 will end up being pick 18 as other clubs match their own bids and GCS have pp no 11.

Yes, must be the season

I'd rather Martin than Papley. But the idea of going to the draft with 3 + 8 gets me thoroughly aroused...

If GWS had pick 3, they could use that on say, Sarong, and then use subsequent picks for Green when a club selects him with their pick. That's why there was talk here that we could split pick 3 with GWS and possibly receive 2 picks inside 15 for 3. Could be win/win.

Is that you Steve?