dl4e

100% agree.

I hope this is correct and staying. You don't want to lose a player like Hogan unless there is something wrong and we might not know that until early in the next season. We do not need to bend over for a player like May. He is not that good.

Well it will be sunset at 5:30 in Tromso and 6:31 in Oslo. It will be dark there before us.

Yes that is true but I am convinced there is something going on we don't know about. Maybe it is a physical thing and we are happy for him to go. Don't know.

So if Hogan had a medical then one would presume he is going but then again maybe mrs fremantle might be unhappy with mr hogans foot.

I cannot understand the desire for May. We have tallish defenders at Casey in Petty and Keilty who may be able to play a similar role as May. Also lever will be back which will make our defence much stronger. If we are to lose Hogan then picks 4 & 5 ( not 9 and 10 ) should go on the 2 best vic kids in the draft. Personally if we don't get 4 and 5 he plays another year with us.

Possible.

They come out with this Neale shizen the day after Hogan paid em a visit. Maybe they now think Hogan will be a no go next year. Don"t know.

Will this thread reach 230 pages by start of trade week on Monday. Amazing.

We are losing a few players. I would keep as he is a good back up and depth player. Be surprised how many games he will get ?

Well that is because we suffer from MFCSS.

10+ players is too much. Ideally between 6 and 8. Keep Tyson but if not try and keep AVB.

I think there may be more to it than how well he gets on with his team mates. A couple of weeks ago all we heard is how happy he is here in melbourne and it has become another home to him. Now it seems to have completly changed. Does he have a girlfriend from Perth ? Does he do stuff that some of his team mates disapprove of ? There may be something going on we don't know about. Maybe he would like to knock on cousins door than win a flag. Hope not.

Okay I will say it but this whole thing stinks.

If we have to lose Hogan I would be going for shiel. May is a waste of time.

Putting it mildly.

Picks 4 and 5 and a player like Brayshaw or Cerra. Freo can get st$%^&%d

Ridiculous. It is utter insanity. I have just read the latter parts of this thread and think it is madness.

I really hope we offer him a position within the club.

Agree. He was horrible today and made some basic skill errors.

Born in 63 so too young to remember it. Like others I just want to see a flag and the older you get the more you pine for it.

It will mean so much to beat the hawks on friday night. Like geelong they have pillaged us. We need revenge.

That was the first stop. Now for Hawthorn.

I would never have Hawkins in the top 6 from both teams. I would have Brayshaw or Stewart.

A sad loss. Been an important player for the club. Real shame he won't get to be a part of september action for us.