DeeSpencer

Looks like the defender has moved before the attacker just, but in this case I’d rather a quick play on call than a 50. We’ll see if our players are more disciplined

I’m tempted but 25m from the boundary at a suboptimal angle, through a fence and surrounded by 2 different types of reptiles (the snakes and Richmond supporters) makes me think it’s best not to.

It’s his field kicking too. His team mates have to be aware of his limitations, but he also has to back himself to hit up some leads. Doesn’t have to be pretty but has to give the forward a chance. Especially if Ben Brown gets up and going. In an ideal world we’d have more wing options and could rotate him to half forward to play a pressure and spread role, especially on the long and thin grounds where there’s less space for the wings. I’d still like to see less joking around and promotion of brand Max and more talk about the team from Max off field. Less of the Hollywood stuff on field should be the main aim. Playing for frees and kicking when he should handball. Like most big guys his best footy is when he’s aggressive at the contest.

No it’s not. Decent handballer on both sides and can chip the ball in uncontested situations. But he struggles to hit targets kicking on the run

Tomlinson turns like a cruise ship, has no physicality or intensity in his game. He’s a lock. After that we have any number of frustrating players all the way from Gawn, Viney, Oliver, Lever to Brayshaw, T Mc, ANB, Smith and Fritsch. I wonder how long it will take for fans to be less impressed with Langdon’s great running and frustrated with his horrendous kicking.

Sounds like the best possible working solution. Defenders will have to quickly decide whether to sag off or man the mark. In fact they may have to decide if they are even going to compete in a contests because once you're jostling with a forward if they out mark you I'd imagine you're pretty much the man on the mark then. The high defensive line is pretty much dead too. Teams will still push up to lock the ball in the forward 50 but they'll have at least 1 sweeper back and once the ball gets to half way they'll drop everyone a long way back. Which will mean a lot of ping pong between the arcs and also a heap of lateral kicking around half back and the middle of the ground

Disagree, as soon as you ban 3rd man up you have to specify who the 2 rucks actually are to stop a decoy situation. If Gawn (ruck), Jackson (FF), Grundy (ruck) and Roughead (FB) were all at a ball up deep in our forward line we could hover Gawn around, have him pull out at the last second and then send Jackson up against Grundy with every chance Roughead bumps in to Jackson as he's defending him, triggering a 3rd man up or block in the ruck scenario. Teams would rort it as much as possible. The umps got really good last year of just identifying when both big men were at the stoppage and getting it going without delay. It just took about 3 years of umpires having conferences with the big boys first which wasn't needed. It's a necessary rule but can be streamlined as it was.

Relatively easy but then they have to add in covid marshals, security, keep the staff and players clear of the public and so on. And if a decent crowd turns up then they are taking away from the product they've sold which is the games in a fortnights time. I'd also imagine the interstate teams would ask why they are limited to 1 practice match if the Victorians roll out 2 full scale matches with crowds. It's not great for us as fans but I can see why they've made them closed sessions in line with the training policies.

Salem will never move to the wing. It’s a gut running position that doesn’t suit his game which is elite distribution out of traffic. The aim should be to move him on ball but we need 2 more additions to the half back kicking ranks before we move him not 1. And we need to clear some of the mids out. In the meantime we can hopefully get Salem and some combination of Bowey, Lockhart, Rivers and even Hunt providing rebound. Richmond use the trio of Houli, Short and Baker to constantly countering with pace and skill.

Remember when we played the kids early for years on end and never got any better? Let’s no repeat that as a philosophy. I expect Laurie will be. I’m not sure we’ll put a 175cm 70kg defender out in round 1 unless he impresses in the scratch games. Jetta and Hibberd are competing with others for a back pocket spot. Melksham was training with the mids. There’s others that they are competing with for spots anyway.

Ticketed events that have covid protocols (zones, player areas etc) to allow for tracing. The next round of practice games starting March 4 are the proper ones, but they limited that to one round and made these games unofficial scratch matches.

I’d like a third tall forward but Brown and T Mc are too similar as lead up half forwards, I wouldn’t play both. We’ll miss the potential upside of someone like Hannan, a mid sizer who can pressure and mark but I’d rather go small. Little guys can still compete in the air if they are smart. I tossed up between Jordon and Sparrow but I think Sparrow’s got a bit more versatility to play forward and wing. Really keen to see both of them in practice games

Way too early round 1 team: FB: Rivers May Hunt HB: Salem Tomlinson Lever C; Langdon Petracca Rosman HF: Spargo T Mc Laurie FF: Chandler Jackson Fritsch Foll: Gawn Oliver Harmes Int: Lockhart, Viney, Sparrow, ANB Pickett, Vanders, Gus, Hibberd, Melksham not considered at this stage due to injury/absence

Bummer, I was hoping they were going to do some defensive drills this preseason

A club official posting on a a fan forum, what could possibly go wrong? Only about 1000 different things. They don't need further channels of communication, they just need to decide if they wish to use them. The official policy which has been communicated is very simple. All trainings are closed. The club can't exact promote a locked training session for fans to come stand around a fence. Should they reply to fans who contact them via email, phone or social media - I'd hope so, but that's a different scenario.

It’s frustrating that I’m sure the media can just text the media manager and get an update when they are doing their rounds. It’s just not the year for fans right now. Hopefully we’ve got a scratch match to report from next weekend

There’s nothing proven about Hunt as a goal kicker. He’s about a goal a game and occasionally bobs up for multiples. His 4 goals in round 18. At least the first and possibly the second came from the wing. And all 4 came from running in to space. I like that we’ve sent him back to half back and will get him to do what he does best which is run.

Yep he’s so powerful he can often get on to his right but he could do with a solid left foot snap. Especially in finals type pressure

Dangerfield, De Goey and Dusty have all played full forward for long stretches and they have better aerial games and can kick on their left and still don’t dominate all that often. It’s really really hard to. With longer quarters I expect Petracca to play more forward this year but he’ll still be a midfielder more than a forward.

Have to ask Gawny whether he’s better than Lochie Filipovic

We’re at least a year away from that and the best result is Jacko becoming a star forward because that’s more valuable. But we could be looking at a 50:50 split as early as next year which is actually not a bad thing. The Eagles had a lot of success using 2 rucks with Cox and Nic Nat. It can really keep the opposition guessing

Jackson, T Mc, Fritsch and rotating mids (we have multiple big body mid options) and smalls. Run, pressure and moving to space matter more than tall targets, especially early in the season. Daw, M Brown, Petty all depth options.

It’s a lot harder to take marks with the defenders converging on you than it is with you floating across the pack. Combine that with poor ability on the ground and bad kicking and it’s not a great combination. That said, Gawn isn’t nearly the player he was at centre bounces since he’s almost eliminated jumping from his game. He wins a lot of hit outs but I’m not sure he’s a net positive in the middle. His ball use around the ground was also pretty stupid at times last year. He can’t kick and should remember that. Jackson might start the year as our number 1 forward and might (small chance) even be too important to ruck. We’ll see on that. But he could also be a very important change of pace in the ruck and we might have to use Max forward to get the right mix.

I agree with most of that except in the photos on the first page he looks as fit as he ever has, all whilst coming back from a serious injury.