The Lobster Effect

One of the channel 7 commentators is "Jack Fitzpatrick"... assuming not our ex player?

Is it bad for me to want Carlton, Melbourne and Sydney to each win the next few and that way we finish off on a high AND get pick 2?

No-ones going to remember our 17th finish next year when we're back in the 8.

5 minutes ago, Wadda We Sing said:

Is Buckley the Right Guy?

Yeah, at least for another couple years.

Injuries + loss of confidence = sound familiar?

Just because you come back from the injury list doesn't mean you return in a good way because of lost fitness/touch etc.

Classic example Mitch Hannan. 

So don't expect players like Melkshem to be back to normal this year after missing so much time.

7 hours ago, Older demon said:

A lot has been written about this year being an aberration....

Good analysis but am feeling depressed after reading it!

1 minute ago, Clintosaurus said:

Yes, and Noah Anderson to go with it. 

That's why I'm not fussed with Carlton overtaking us today. If this seasons going to be bad it might as well be truly shizen. Regroup over preseason with players ready to go on day 1, with the number 2 pick and an easier draw. 

3 minutes ago, dees189227 said:

Hey does this mean if we finish bottom 3 or 4 we will get a soft draw next year?

Yes.

They categorise the draw according to a 1-6, 7-12, 13-18 finish. 

West Coast's confidence is shown by naming 3 debutants on their extended bench...

15 minutes ago, DeeZee said:

This coach continues to rush in underdone players , why?

Well, mathematically it was our last chance to make the finals so was worth a last roll of the dice. 

Now that it's all over red rover they might put a few players in for early surgeries..

Match-winner

Is Teague trying to make Judd look stupid? 3 wins outta 5....

I thought pies were a sneaky chance with their top 4 chances on the line but didn't have the balls to tip them...

11 minutes ago, samcantstandya said:

Why is Hannah not under scrutiny?

I agree Hannah Gadsby is a bit overrated.

What a joke.

Firstly on Gold Coast - They got picks 2, 3 and 6 last year so need to be patient. (and if any of their picks leave they just need to negotiate a return like GWS do) 

They've lost 3 games under a goal they easily could have won (Exhibit A vs us)

They've made a couple of really poor draft picks (not even referring to the pick 2 for Weller trade but the pick swaps with West Coast and the one with Brisbane this year). 

Carlton are finally improving (Exhibit B vs us) and as much as it pains me to say are on the up. 

Saints aren't that bad, (Exhibit C vs is), a classic mid table club at the moment and don't deserve it until they've been bottom 4 for another few years. 

7 minutes ago, dees189227 said:

Is that most Tommy has ever kicked? 

Equal highest (he kicked 6 vs Collingwood last year).

Hopefully his ankle comes good for the last quarter.

Were people going for Sydney because they hate the bombers or because they want a gap between other teams so we get a better draft pick?

Is the pies 2019 over?

4 hours ago, chookrat said:

What happened re Joel Smith's groin? Havent heard much about this, seems he has flown under the radar. 

Don't ask mate, don't ask.... 

11 minutes ago, david_neitz_is_my_dad said:

Blues will do us in next week

It's at least 50/50 unfortunately...

1 hour ago, Mach5 said:

Hirst would be my choice with pick 3.

Dunkley if Hirst is gone.

We've been linked with both Hirst and Lowson so if Carlton go for Deluca then we should end up with one of them. 

I'm guessing Gold Coast go for Dunkley.

1 hour ago, DV8 said:

 

Can teams trade picks,  in mid-season drafts?

Nup

4 minutes ago, dazzledavey36 said:

Zac Williams has done a hammy for GWS.

And Mummy could be suspended for a hit on Murphy. Even if it's judged as accidental Murphy has gone to hospital so you think Mummy's in strife.

In an incident that is likely to draw the attention of Match Review Officer Michael Christian, the right knee of the Giants' ruckman made forceful contact with Murphy's rib region.

Will Bolton survive a 100 point loss?

Takeaways from tonight:

What a scrappy game. 

Essendon are over-rated.

"Fantayzia" sounds better than "Fant-a-sea-a". 

Bruce needs to retire. 

53 minutes ago, KingDingAling said:

Freeman might be worth looking at. He is injury prone but if we give nothing then he'd be worth a gamble. We need pace and game breakers.

11 odd hammies later.. unfortunately he's lost the pace he had. That's why the Saints got rid of him.