-
Posts
16,348 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
6
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Store
Everything posted by whatwhat say what
-
so will he come back even slower?
-
my mfcss is kicking in when things are glum there's worse to come!
-
everything was in the aints' favour and they still couldn't get the job done like ever other team ranked 6-13, including us, they're pretenders in 2020
-
not sure it's the same case when it's a free agency like crouch or viney - generally those conversations start up to 18 months out may was pre-agency, so it made sense that he moved when he did i wouldn't want either crouch while we have all of oliver, petracca, viney, brayshaw, harmes, and sparrow
-
reminds me of paul johnson i don't rate him and i believe he's on significant coin; if we were to chase him it'd be for a replacement of t mac
-
i don't see why he wouldn't pick us he's an outside player looking for a new team; we're crying out for his type, and he would get plenty of opportunities with us i can't actually seeing him being worth much - he seems to be constantly breaking down and when fit is unable to force his way into geelong's 22 third / fourth rounder? geelong hardly need the picks tho narkle and one of their first round picks for viney, when we match whatever they're offering him and 'force' the trade?
-
not a huge amount seeing as he was in a one- or two-year contract
-
these things don't just pop up overnight if cats are actually after him, they probably approached him in 2019
-
possibly only in their assigned 'groups'
-
In the fortunate position that he’s contracted so he needs a big preseason ahead of 2021
-
this the top 5 look like premiership contenders, but both the bears and meth coke are currently beset by serious injury (gov did him hammy for the latter tonight), while all the teams 6-13 are pretenders, freo and sydney are rebuilding and capable but not consistent, while the bottom three of crows, kangas, and hawks are pretty ordinary too many teams, too many ordinary footballers
-
Shorter Qtrs & 28 Rounds in 2021?
whatwhat say what replied to Demonland's topic in Melbourne Demons
i actually don't mind shortened quarters but, really, i would also not opposed massively reduced interchange allowance and 16-6 as opposed to 18-4 line-ups ultimately, this is wholly and solely about players not being willing to take pay cuts -
wants a small fortune has completely failed to impose himself on the game in 2020; he's hardly alone there among key forwards
-
fortunately he's restricted so if the offer isn't enough to get us back into the first round they'll have to trade for him; they have three first round picks i'll take two kthxbye i would expect even if the cats do make an offer for him we'd match and force a trade it would be very sad to see him go
-
i would like to see the actual quote where he says that the club asked him to put on 10kg for this season - i had never heard that before recent revelations on this forum agree with everyone that it makes zero sense in the context of what sort of player he has been at his best, how modern football is played, and his injury history
-
you'd think he'd perfectly suit our needs as a quick outside type
-
Gary Pert on The Deebrief
whatwhat say what replied to Sir Why You Little's topic in Melbourne Demons
pert handled exactly as you'd expect an experienced ceo would i basically heard as 'if goodwin loses the last two games then we'll have to have a serious think about it' -
carn the camry's!
-
i'm going to presume not it just goes to show how ordinary all the teams below about 5th on the ladder actually are at the moment
-
Who should our next coach be?
whatwhat say what replied to Pickett2Jackson's topic in Melbourne Demons
he's not coaching essendon; he's just having a superannuation year reckon the pharmacist will be at freo as a senior assistant or what have you next year -
it's all deckchairs on the titanic unfortunately our list is bereft of quality outside the top half dozen or so players, and our coaching department is clearly substandard
-
dunno how there can be bad blood with balme considering everyone from that time is well and truly gone scott has just been appointed boss of football victoria as the afl shift jobs around to find jobs for the boys, hasn't he? also a bit contradictory to ask for "someone from a recent Premiership winning club that has a good culture which is also ruthless and demands high standards" and then also say "Alan Richardson could also be moved to that role" in terms of managing the soft cap i agree that richardson going into that position makes sense...i can't fathom how we gave him a five year deal mind you, i have no idea what he actually does - what is a director of coaching? whatever way - mahoney has got to go
-
Who should our next coach be?
whatwhat say what replied to Pickett2Jackson's topic in Melbourne Demons
this is probably the most likely outcome -
Who should our next coach be?
whatwhat say what replied to Pickett2Jackson's topic in Melbourne Demons
Head of footy - Alistair Clarkson Coach - Adem Yze Forward coach - John Barker Midfield coach - Jordan Lewis Backline coach - Cam Bruce -
Demonland Player of the Year - Rd 16
whatwhat say what replied to Demonland's topic in Melbourne Demons
Gawn was awful I thought 6 Viney 5 Petracca 4 Rivers 3 May 2 Tomlinson 1 Oliver