Jump to content

whatwhat say what

Life Member

Everything posted by whatwhat say what

  1. Speed forwards are rolled gold in modern footy Watson would be a great addition But I’m still all in on getting Reid
  2. Or Danny Hughes Yet Nathan Carroll gets a look in Our mar comms and digital integration are appalling
  3. mfcde.es/457Ctmj Love the concept although not sure for our 165th year means much Hate the execution Embarrassing
  4. Gets a lot of football, but burns it All of Oliver, Viney, Brayshaw, Sparrow, and JJ are ahead of him for the inside mid role
  5. that just means that they'll force a trade ben mckay won't be at north in 2024
  6. not to mention a bloke named jason taylor...
  7. i doubt we can afford to bring him in tbh already on big coin, regularly injured, and always unavailable he has to pretend to be a twin and play for the baggers
  8. it'd be nice if these draft guides that proliferate these days would give that sort of guide... harley reid: ceiling: christian petracca floor: luke tapscott daniel curtin: ceiling: matthew pavlich floor: cale morton and so on and so forth
  9. our average mcg crowd - home or home & away - would be extremely healthy
  10. they were disorganised and completely rattled losing libba was a signficant blow for their set-up
  11. the comparison he's been getting is pavlich, i believe? if that would be the ceiling, would that make cale morton the floor? kicking action looks smooth
  12. i tend to think that this is probably correct
  13. you stop that right now with yr logical thought and statistical data and evidence that makes me doubt myself! i for one still think having two genuine ruckman throws out our structure but perhaps they'll give it another go this week
  14. brown's kicking - other than the one he tried to roll thru from 3m out that hit the post - was superb i thought really nicely weighted to the leading player going i50 and seemed to make 'good' decisions looks like he is definitely going to be on our list in 2024 and beyond wouldn't surprise me if he becomes a best 23 type
  15. you leave bill simmons outta this!
  16. sen's tom morris also thinks he's going to ask for a trade at the end of the year... All eyes are on Grundy, who is likely to request a trade if he’s stuck in the VFL at the end of the season. Whether Melbourne grants this request is another matter. As we speak they are saying no. But clubs do that all the time then relent eventually. Fremantle released a statement squashing Rory Lobb's trade request last year then traded him a week later.
  17. hunter has been very good all year he's not getting dropped
  18. why are we so flat to start games at the moment? it wasn't a problem earlier in the year but it's clearly one currently
  19. not necessarily gc17 are still going to want to jettison that early pick something that often gets forgotten is that clubs can only go into the draft with as many list spots as they have available
  20. would expect he will be gone by our pick 6, as it will be pushed out to, you would think still gotta focus on getting #1 and harley reid
  21. jai newcombe is some player
  22. following the vfl game, i would think... OUT: jordon, grundy IN: spargo, tomlinson smith forward and hibb remains the sub
  23. really surprised by the positivity about tomlinson can't see him getting back into the afl side based on that performance, particularly as more good afl teams are going 'smaller' rather than 'taller' dunstan, spargo, laurie, woey 2.0 the best of the afl-listed players edit: although, in saying that, hawks do appear to have multiple 'bigs' that it might be handy to have tommo help play on alongside may