Sir Why You Little

Clouded my view?? And your view is perfect of course yeah right Salem has been on our list since 2014 and since then has been underwhelming, although you wouldn't know it reading threads on here

That may explain it, yes of course. We agree on this one

I was just agreeing with what Jackaub wrote, why don't you have a go at him? or do you just like going the man...

Yawn

Many on here consider him elite, a word that is often over used

Agreed. Far too inconsistent for all the acolades he gets on here. Yes he is a good kick, but that is of no use if he is not on the ground

Mr. Poetry and TGR are just plain wrong on this topic, but they will keep going until Jordan Lewis plays his last game in 1-2 years and then say "See i told you so" if we make finals this year and WIN a final with Jordan playing in it then his recruitment has been well worthwhile even if he retires at seasons end. I expect he will play again in 2018, never expected him to play 2019

How awful

Fair enough, as he has talent on his side but he hasn't done himself a lot of favours lately wrong time of the year to be on the outer

I have never doubted he has excellent skills at all. But have we had good value out of him since 2014? I don't think we have i am looking at the past 3 years, not just the last few games. He is certainly not an "untouchable" if the right deal is offered, but i wouldn't trade him unless an excellent player was available.

Nothing wrong with knowing the worth of your assets. A deal can always be around the corner

So would i, he is worth quite a bit on the trade table i suspect. Only worth trading for top shelf. I am happy if he stays, absolutely. But it is debatable as to whether we have got good value out of him since 2014. He has missed a lot of games...

Exactly. Salem has talent, no doubt. But he is still on the edge of the senior side. His job last week was to strive to be BOG, not to get reported and rubbed out. His worth to the MFC is still undecided either way....

Not at all. I had my house valued last month by The Bank it has gone up nicely thank you i now have more investment leverage and i still own the house

Don't misquote me. I stated it would be interesting to see what Salem is worth on the trade table, i did not say that he should be traded...

Exactly. In rows, like dolls hair!!

Clayton's first Q on Sunday was massive. He was in everything. Rough stuff and smooth. The Umps will notice him

Correct.... in 2000 Shane had a very good solid season, but to win a Charlie suprised even the most diehard Demon

His last Quarter on Sunday was huge. He helped thwart at least 2 Saints attacking runs

He sure did. Sewn into his skull!!!

You got that part right...

Serious consideration... Salem must be a little shaky with his form/injuries and bad report from last week Trade month is gonna be great this year if we make September. Players will love to play at The G when it is full of Red and Blue Demons the Northern side of the G was chockers last sunday

We haven't smashed anyone this year, I didn't expect to, which is why losing to Freo and Nought Melb got me angry. We should be eyeing of a top 4 spot on points alone, but life is never perfect!!

We are still learning to win, the kill will come later. I am just happy we slammed dunked a 1st Quarter at this stage We did Steady it up really well in the last Quarter... the Crush will happen when the kids get match hardened.

We would have won about 6 games for the year without him. A huge get at the point where St. Kilda got to within 4 points of us, i thought we were gone Jordan obviously didn't feel the same way and he was actually able to do something about it. I just had to stress out!!