Sir Why You Little

Exactly. Nothing more.

What’s McCarthy done? steak knives clog up lists

If a player wants to go now, they go 99 times in 100 A contract is no more than a handshake, they are broken regularly that’s what free agency is

Wow! What a strange response. You are one tough emotionless bastard aern’t you..

Players who are 1 year into the system are requesting trades to specific clubs. Contracts are worthless if a player wants to go. All players are now free agents, i knew it would happen when Free Agency started. Luke Ball set a precedent, it has just evolved from that

No i have not. My stance has not changed. If Freo want to buy Hogan they pay Top $$ or [censored] off Quite simple. Key Forwards are hard to find and we should know. In 160 seasons we have NEVER had a 100 goal kicker. Hogan hasn’t peaked yet... So pay ? up or leave.

You don’t understand. ANY CONTRACT can now be broken. This by in philosophy is dying. For the players it is a job. I have no problem if Hogan is traded. BUT I want top dollar ? You are prepared to put him on the front lawn and see who picks him up 2 days ago YOU agreed with me when i passed on a conversation that said Hogan would play off Half Back next year. Your facts (opinions) change every 20 minutes and are written in concrete. Me in La La land, take a look in the mirror Range Rover

That article says nothing. 50 cents each way....

Fairly lame joke. My humour is more educated. I grew up with Peter Sellers and George Carlin...

There are some huge statements being extracted from read ends with this saga.

What kind of talk is this??

That is an opinion, not a fact. Contracts mean absolutely nothing now. Who cares if a player signs an extension for 3 years. They just walk anyway... i have no problem with Jesse. Infact I sympathize with him for what he has gone through in the last 18 months. Are both of your balls fit and healthy??

Being stuck with Cale Morton was a lot worse. No doubt about it

This is the bit that gets me angry. Sell the trade they have for multiple larger numbers and then say the deal is off. That is Primary School etiquette

I am not saying any of that. But he had an awful year off field. It’s different to most cases. I have no problems with him taking time out to evaluate his life. I am sure he loves the MFC regardless

You are not factoring in the death of his father or his cancer issues

Freo have been into Jesse for years. If they really wanted him, they would pay. If Jesse was 29 i would agree with you, but he is not, he is 23 and not even peaked yet. He is worth 2 First Roond picks, particularly now that th “Hands in the back rule” is gone. You are prepared to undersell him to just get the deal done. The MFC realize he is an asset, if you want him pay up. The Shockers threw rubbish [censored] off

The MFC have no reason to spin on this one. In some ways we have been to open. But i think that is Josh being a good operator. We have put a price on Jesse and it has been knocked back 2 first round picks is a fair price for a 23 year old forward, who can play.

I don’t think the MFC are spinning. I think we are happy either way to have Jessie or not. You must factor in his family issues. I think all other parties are spinning. Jesse passed a medical then they offer rubbish. Deals off

I believe the statement put out by the MFC AND NOTHING HAS COME OUT SINCE THEN... Absolutely nothing, unless you believe Ricky Nixon

You are guessing. As you have done for days now...

He may well do it after his plane lands too. Fremantle are throwing rubbish, so the deal is off unless their attitude changes. Jesse Hogan has said nothing...

and also happy to stay if a deal cannot be reached. You forgot that bit The kid lost his Dad and had Testicular Cancer this year. He is allowed to weigh up options.

Where is the “uncommitted Hogan” i am yet to hear this spoken anywhere except on this site. NOTHING HAS CHANGED SINCE LAST NIGHT.

That’s next year. A lot changes in 365 days. I am interested in next season.