Whispering_Jack

I have only saw a little of him playing earlier in the season and it must be hard to determine his value at the draft given a serious injury to each knee, the most recent requiring ACL surgery which will keep him out of action for at least half, if not all, of 2023. He’s likely to be taken in the early to mid 20s. If we really have an eye on him, I’m wondering if a swap of picks 13 and 37 (1695 points) to West Coast for 20 and 26 (1651 points) would be considered? There are no guarantees of course but if George is the player we want, we could still possibly get him at 20 and be in an improved position with our second selection at 26. Just thinking outside the square.

On this day back in 1989 in London, Queen Elizabeth II was sitting on the throne, Margaret Thatcher was the Prime Minister and Melbourne played Essendon for the Foster’s Cup at the Oval. It’s pizzing down here in Melbourne, so relax, sit down, have a sip of the sponsor’s product and watch the game in full …

Chris Doerre’s early 3 rounder… ESPN's early three-round phantom draft for 2022 - every pick of the first three rounds

The big question is how many Category B rookies is a club permitted to have on its list at any one time? I would hope the answer is three as otherwise the club would be precluded from picking Finn Emile-Brennan as a Category B rookie if the limit was two per club.

North appears to have set their sights on Harry Sheezel - a freak forward who ticks all the boxes. This is why A fair appraisal of this top prospect but if you knew Harry, you wouldn’t use the word ‘obsessed’. The correct word is ‘focused’ - his head is on his shoulders and for the last 4 or 5 years he’s worked hard to get where he is now. I think he’ll be happy to stay in Melbourne as well.

Nice effort but I believe that Gold Coast has stated they would use their first pick on a midfielder so if true, that would rule Jefferson out at that selection.

Most AFL clubs have announced at least one set of delistings and the time has come for a consideration of who among the delistings should be offered a second or third chance. The delisted players who should be given another chance

Buddy is listed at 199cm.

It’s a story from the Murdoch press and I think the information is not dissimilar to that in the story contained in Chaser J’s link above.

eth-dogs 2022 phantom draft (Big footy) First Round: Pick 1, Greater Western Sydney: Aaron Cadman (Greater Western Victoria Rebels, 194/88, Key Forward) Pick 2, Brisbane: Will Ashcroft (Sandringham Dragons, 182/82, Inside Midfielder) Matching North Melbourne’s bid. Pick 3, North Melbourne: Harry Sheezel (SD, 184/77, Forward/Midfielder) Pick 4, North Melbourne: Elijah Tsatas (Oakleigh Chargers, 187/80, Balanced Midfielder) Pick 5, Essendon: George Wardlaw (OC, 182/82, IM) Pick 6, Gold Coast: Bailey Humphrey (Gippsland Power, 186/86 F/M) Pick 7, Hawthorn: Jhye Clark (Geelong Falcons, 181/77, IM) Pick 8, Geelong: Mattaes Phillipou (Woodville-West Torrens Eagles, 192/83, M/F) Pick 9, West Coast: Reuben Ginbey (East Perth, 188/81, Midfielder/Defender) Pick 10, St. Kilda: Cameron Mackenzie (SD, 187/80, IM) Pick 11, Carlton: Olli Hotton (SD, 181/79, F/M) Pick 12, Western Bulldogs: Jed Busslinger (EP, 196/82, Key Defender) Pick 13, West Coast: Elijah Hewett (Swan Districts, 185/84, IM) Pick 14, Melbourne: Harry Barnett (West Adelaide, 202/93, Ruck) Pick 15, Sydney: Jacob Konstanty (GP, 176/70, Small Forward) Pick 16, Essendon (live trade of pick 22 and Essendon F2 for pick 16): Oliver Hollands (Murray Bushrangers, 184/71, IM) Pick 17, Collingwood: Matthew Jefferson (OC, 194/76, KF) Pick 18, Sydney: Brayden George (MB, 185/87, Medium Forward) Pick 19, Greater Western Sydney: Charlie Clarke (SD, 182/75, SF) Second Round: Pick 20, Greater Western Sydney: Mitchell Szybkowski (Dandenong Stingrays, 186/84, IM) Pick 21, West Coast: Sam Gilbey (Claremont, 188/71, Medium Defender) Pick 22, Western Bulldogs: Josh Weddle (OC, 193/82, Medium Defender) Pick 23, Greater Western Sydney (live trade): Lachlan Cowan (Tasmania Devils, 188/81, MD) Pick 24, Brisbane: Jaspa Fletcher (Sherwood, 184/73 Outside Midfielder). Matching Adelaide’s bid. Pick 25, Adelaide: Isaac Keeler (North Adelaide, 197/83, KF/R) Pick 26, Essendon: Alwyn Davey jr (Oakleigh, 180/74, SF/M) Matching Hawthorn’s bid Pick 27, Hawthorn: Darcy Jones (SwD, 175/63, SF) Pick 28, Collingwood: Henry Hustwaite (DS, 194/84, KD) Pick 29, West Coast: Ed Allen (Claremont, 194/82, Utility) Pick 30, Collingwood: Lewis Hayes (Eastern Ranges, 197/81, KD) Pick 31, St. Kilda: Jakob Ryan (Glenelg, 189/77, MD) Pick 32, Carlton: Koby Burgiel (GP, 183/77, Half Back) Pick 33, Fremantle: Nick Sadler (Sturt, 179/72, OM) Pick 34, Greater Western Sydney: Noah Long (Bendigo Pioneers, 178/74, SF/M) Pick 35, St. Kilda: Max Gruzewski (OC, 192/84, Utility) Pick 36, Port Adelaide: Adam D'Aloia (WWT, 186/86, IM) Pick 37, Melbourne: James Van Es (GWV, 196/97, KD)

MELBOURNE 3.1.19 5.1.31 7.2.44 9.4.58 GOLD COAST SUNS 0.0.0 1.0.6 1.3.9 1.3.9 GOALS MELBOURNE Harris 3 Hore Zanker 2 Fitzsimon D Pearce GOLD COAST SUNS Dupuy

Harris again. Lead is 25.

Tayla Harris makes it a trifecta 19 - 0 late in the first quarter.

Second to Kate Hore in her 51st!

Whichever player the recruiters consider is the best available.

In: Caris, Wilson, Brown Out: L.Pearce (concussion), Sherriff (inj.), Goldrick (inj.)

I tried this exercise with the Pick 13 thread to help in understanding this discussion in context. This is a look at the last five drafts and the choices made at around this selection. 2017 36. Charlie Constable (Geelong) 37. Harry Petty (Melbourne) 38. Jack Petruccelle (West Coast) 39. Nathan Murphy (Collingwood) 2018 36. Tom Berry (Brisbane Lions) 37. Laitham Vandermeer (Western Bulldogs) 38. Irving Mosquito (Essendon) 39. Jarrod Cameron (West Coast) 2019 36. Elijah Taylor (Sydney) 37. Keidean Coleman (Brisbane Lions) 38. Nick Bryan (Essendon) 39. Chad Warner (Sydney) 2020 36. Charlie Lazzaro (North Melbourne) 37. Corey Durdin (Carlton) 38. James Rowe (Adelaide) 39. Josh Eyre (Essendon) 2021 36. Jake Soligo (Adelaide) 37. Rhett Bazzo (West Coast) 38. Miller Bergman (North Melbourne) 39. Blake Howes (Melbourne) Another Harry Petty or Chad Warner would be a handy addition to the list.

Not entirely helpful if you only hold pick 13 Twomey’s preview for the first four picks of the National Draft

This sort of recruitment rarely turns out anything more than neutral in impact to a club. The feeling is that most people consider that it’s doomed to failure and that Shache will be around for a couple of seasons and get delisted. At the heart of it, we have a player who seven years ago won the Larke Medal for b & f in the National Under 18 Championships and was considered good enough to be pick 2 at the draft at the end of the year i.e. close to the 2015 version of Aaron Cadman who has half of the football world salivating today. The question is whether the club will take the time to unpack why he’s now at his third club and whether he can be mentored to iron out the faults he had when drafted or subsequently picked up along the way to improve him as a footballer. Otherwise, he languishes at Casey and perhaps plays a dozen games of AFL in 2023/4 and then disappears off the scene.

If we did that, they wouldn’t come to coach at Casey which is 50k from the CBD.

The big question is whether they release the review’s findings (probably not) but there are many aspects to the way in which a club operates and the coach is always the easiest target. Their recruiting and player development leaves a lot to be desired and their fitness people would surely be under the microscope. At least they must have plenty of dollars because the payout to Ratten is likely to be substantial and they will also no doubt let some of his coaching team go as well. They were 8-3 at the midpoint of the season. Did it have to come to this?

This amusement parlour in the heart of the Gold Coast used to be called “Grundys” many years ago. I’m starting a petition to have it changed back to its original name.

Local paper up on the Gold Coast writes about the Weideman trade as a massive recruiting coup by the Bombers

Well done guys but one clarification is required on the subject of whether James Jordon was dropped at the end of the season. He was in fact, named as the “medical sub” for the Round 23 match v Brisbane and was not used. He played in the Casey VFL team against the Brisbane reserves on the following day and then injured his foot at training during the following week and missed out on playing in the finals.