VoiceOfReason

I'd move both on. Try prize out a promising young talent from another side.

I agree. I'd be looking to build a midfield around VIney. Get Viney to lead the younger brigade, he'd add protection, and show them how a leader applies themselves. There is a reason North wanted him.

Petracca and Oliver, thanks for your service.

Rivers was smashing them early, and then the genius puts him down back, where he has barely touched it since. Outside of Rivers, Viney tries hard. I'd be moving Petracca and Oliver on at years end.

Unathletic and not much chop, was a baffling decision to select him ahead of Wilson - then and now.

Who is playing on Curtin?

Im not only in the goodbye Goodwin camp, but I won't even be watching any more games whilst he remains as coach. Our gameplan is just too frustrating to watch, not to mention our wasteful forward 50 entries, and inaccurate goal kicking. I can find better ways to spend the weekend than watch this current side. Ive been a 40 year member, but won't be renewing next year as it stands.

Langford is different gravy. If posters are turning on Windsor its because - at least this year - hes been a terrible kick. Turnover merchants frustrate posters. In terms of Windsor vs Caddy, ill leave that for the talent scouts. Caddy wasn't the only one on the board, Curtin looks quality.

The players say they want to play for Goodwin, but actions suggest otherwise. The effort might be there, but that is about it. Wasteful football in 2/3's of the ground. Oliver and Petracca looked to have checked out.

Well outlined. I agree with that. Its the club that continues to make poor decisions. Therefore it should come as little surprise that we are stuck with a low IQ coach like Goodwin.

Port are sh*thouse. They get gifted everything in home games, its why they achieve nothing down the G. Im switching it off, the umpiring against us most weeks is criminal. I will watch the replay should we win. Have a good game everyone,

I just wish we could pull the trigger now and get rid of him. In other sports, this would have already been done - a long time ago now. It all comes down to efficiency and effectiveness. How many inside 50's and score board inefficiency do we have to cop, before a coach gets the sack. Its just ridiculous.

That is exactly right. Financial. All comes down to $$$$$.

We have no forwards. They are hopeless. Zero forward 50 smarts.

We've been doing this for years. Working our tails off - for no scoreboard reward. Then the wall breaks, and we have a solid loss. In any other sport, we'd be looking to change our head coach. For too long now we've had to watch this, and our players have had to play under it.

Goody will see his contract out. We haven't had a competent board in place, and our administration has been a mess. Be interesting to see who replaces him when the time does come.

The type of effort I'd expect from a bottom rung side in 2025. Our ladder position is a reflection of where we are at. Hopefully at years end, there is a review, and changes are made.

Very jumpy. A bit shell shocked. Don't miss Jordon. He could be fitter.

Its a shame he don't have much talent. He plays a much needed role, as we have that gap to fill. Wish it were Jacko. Can see why we won one.

We shouldve won by 20 goals. Good win. But [censored]. Very inaccurate. Cannot always be saved by class (Kozi). A byproduct of having a ruck man as forward coach in recent times - is that we convert with the accuracy of a ruck man.

If JL was still coaching Sydney they'd be up for 15 goals. Coaches matter. Whether it is them WANTING to play for their coach, or just simply the coach not being up to scratch. Many variables. This game is rubbish. One of the worst games ive watched this year.

Gawn Trac Windsor Turner Chandler

Be hard to win now they have their tails up. Over there its a different kettle of fish. Once you give them a sniff at home - its hard to swing back momentum. We wont win now. They kicked 6 points before they kicked a goal, then kicked 4, lucky for us Reid missed a gimme. Gawn playing well, Tracc playing well, Langford dominating, Windsor started well. Rivers sh*thouse, Tholstrup hopeless, Melksham - please retire.

Not really. Flynn struggles against tall men. Even Turner could give Max a chop out and not cop too much of a beating. Max dont need a back up against a ruckman the quality of Flynn.

Best first year player at the club since Oliver. I must be watching a different game to most.