Chook

Am I the only one who thinks he got tackled unfairly 5 times out of 6?

Nick Riewoldt has been very good this year, and I suspect his rankings have been badly hampered by a concussion in one round and a knee injury in another. I'd take a fully fit Riewoldt over any of those other players even now, at his age.

I don't want to get into a nitpick debate either, but I'd rank them: 1 Riewoldt 2 Vince 3 Jones 4 Montagna

I think in Dunn's case he can. Maybe not in that instance though. One criticism I have of Dunn is that he's too willing to put the ball over the boundary line when he could otherwise win a 50/50 ball.

Needs to put on some height and weight I'd say!

I like the way he goes about it.

Let's. It's probably gone by now anyway.

That's a little homophobic. Of course, this isn't the forum for airing that sort of thing anyway. Not that there's anything wrong with that.

The best thing about this video is that every time you think "Geez, he can't possibly kick this!" he puts it straight through the middle. Also, did anyone notice how many of Jesse's goals were basically from the goalsquare? Talk about a cherry picker.

Even if this were a joke, how could you possibly think it’s a clever one?

I believe in Tom Scully.

Yep. We must use Hogan’s games/marks/goals tally from his first year in order to be fair. G / M / G 0 / 0 / 0 What a dud. Seriously, how else can we compare Hogan with those players.

Actually, no they don’t. That’s the point.

Luke Hodge sprays his teammates fairly often. Coaches yell at their players. Forwards have been demanding better of midfielders since Moses wore short pants. It’s good. EDIT: Obviously there can be too much of a good thing though.

In order to get out of the mire, we need everyone to demand better of their team mates. I’m okay with it, TBH.

It’s pronounced moldy-kulchuralizm

Cripps should be in the conversation, but only to say: “Cripps would win any other year, but Jesse Hogan is a once in a generation forward, so…."

Batman is real in that the character called "Batman" has been in existence for over 70 years (longer than you, likely) and has definitely never flown under his own power during all that time. Smart-arse.

Is Jack Viney aware that not even the real Batman can fly?

You just need some JW Black.

Liam Jurrah is by far the biggest wasted talent I’ve seen in my time following footy. Such a sporting tragedy and an indictment on both him and Australia’s failure to support indigenous culture in a positive way.

The klink is what happens when we're toasting our Grand Final victory.

Heard him mentioned as the worst ever Coleman Medallist last week. That got me riled up.

Yes Yes Yes this is amazing!!!!

Sorry, but bad knees should be out. We need good genes in the pool from both sides.