Everything posted by Chook
-
AFLW: SF vs Adelaide
Shelley Heath has been SOOOO good all year, but that game was massive from her. The run, the (mostly) great disposal. The TACKLING!!!
-
Kozzi Pickett - Will he be an all time MFC great?
Just getting over two of our all time greats walking out the door, so for my own sanity I'm going to say "No, he'll plod along."
-
Farewell Christian Petracca
Personally I'm glad I never have to watch him burst form a stoppage and sky the ball to the opposition ever again. Except when he plays us, in which case he's welcome to do it.
-
Equalisation AFL
The AFL is willing to let VFL clubs die while paying snoopy dog dog millions to sing at the half-time show. I don't think equalisation is really their main priority.
-
Farewell Clayton Oliver
CLARRY: “Am I really that bad for club culture? No, it the MFC who are wrong.”
-
NON-MFC: Finals Week 02
Good for you. Peace out.
-
NON-MFC: Finals Week 02
He has served his penalty. Lay off him.
-
Rule changes proposed for 2026
Call me crazy but I've watched boundary throw ins for my whole life and never had a problem with them. At what point is the sport I grew up watching no longer the same sport?
-
Who Will Be Our Next Coach?
If we sign Bevo for 5 years I might legit give up AFL and just support the Women's for a bit.
-
Demons Ponder New Strategy Boss
My membership. I wrote it in the contract: "I want a new strategy boss." So you can thank me, though I'm not sure my membership will entirely cover it.
-
GAMEDAY: Rd 24 vs Collingwood
I am so sick of Petracca's blind roosts inside 50.
-
GAMEDAY: Rd 24 vs Collingwood
You could see this coming from a mile away.
-
Intraccuracy!!!
Makes his dribbler from the boundary to send every Melbourne fan into hysterics even the more puzzling. (You know the one.)
-
What's Collingwood ever done for Melbourne?
I always liked Chris Dawes. Shame he wasn't a better footballer.
-
AFLW SEASON OPENS THIS WEEK
Any update on Tayla Harris' ankle? She's a joy to watch when she's in full flight. Been absolutely cruelled with injury over the past couple of years.
-
Roosy's roost
Paul Roos for next MFC coach. Wouldn't that be wild!
-
How you doing?
A hair behind Gus in the "Magic Formula" rankings.
-
When will Melbourne break these embarrassing records?
2021 is in my vernacular
-
Simon Goodwin respect thread.
At worst, a WAFL Mickey Mouse premiership coach. At best, the man who gave us everything we ever dreamed of. And yet all dreams must come to an end eventually. I salute the dream; for what is sport, but dreams made manifest? Thank you Goody. We'll meet you further on up the road.
-
Who Will Be Our Next Coach?
Please god no. I'd rather stick with Goodwin than "acquire" Hinkley.
-
Who Will Be Our Next Coach?
I want a name coach who can command the respect of our (IMO self-absorbed and entitled) senior players from day one. Adam Simpson would be my preference from this vantage point. He is a premiership coach who led his team to a premiership based on a KPP-based (forward craft mandatory) premiership. That's what we're lacking. But I don't know what no-name assistants are out there, so I am open to anything.
-
How you doing?
I'm good. I think it's the right decision. It's a chance for everyone who cares about Melbourne and their part in the Melbourne story to reflect, take stock, and think about what they want moving forward. EDIT: I include Simon Goodwin in that as well. He's a great coach, and I'm 100% sure he will coach another side one day. He's as rolled gold as they come, but his time at Melbourne was well and truly up.
-
From anger to action: A call for constructive feedback to leadership
Sounds like a no true scotsman supporter to me.
-
From anger to action: A call for constructive feedback to leadership
I'm a supporter. It's not my responsibility to run the club. It's not even my responsibility to financially support the club. They play well, I buy in. That's where the relationship ends.
-
2025 MRO & Tribunal
This will be an easy listen on a Monday night: https://x.com/1116sen/status/1947178476747837859 David King reckons it's May's responsibility to pull out of the contest when he thinks he'll get there second. Lovely. Imagine all the contests players would pull out of if they had to be sure they'd get there first.