picket fence

You must be joking ?? Weeds OUT?? What game were you watching ? he competed, did what was asked, crunched a few packs, presenting crumbing opportunities and when Tommy was out was our only tall, kicked 2 vital goals, and will get better with confidence AND GAMES. He stays in for the rest of the year in my book unless his form drops right of!

If its not "Rocket Science" and many experts on this forum could see it why couldn't Simon?? Therin lies a bigger problem!

And, also given his adversity in trying to get back and the Dees offering him a lifeline, It is fitting that we stand as one in support! That should be ALL AFL Not just Deees Well done young man and Club in maintaining this obvious stance!?

Ok I stand corrected Il,l review game and as as I have said Nev is a favourite!

NO WAY Who knows what one more head knock may do !! DEFINATELY NOT!

Weeds should NEVER have been out of that side, But Goody knows best right!?? Im not sure but if Nev was on Rankine for the most then he was beaten. i LOVE nev but he appears to be slowing down.

Ah NOOO1

YEP DELUSIONAL IN FACT but Ill take a win anytime!

Not sure what you mean by that "Not the sharpest tool in the shed"? Are you talking in a footy sense?? If so how do you know that he isn't being over coached? From the point of view that he has been instructed to kick the ball more often?? As I see it he isn't doing the "Instinctive"things as much anymore! If I was his coach I would say to him take the game on and do instinctively!

Bowlers run at $2.99 per bottle should do it for you uncle! At Dans of course!!?

I will buy a Suns membership in the realization, that they are going in a different direction to us ..... UP!

Good lets do it!

Yep Jack Viney is very limited footballer, Iv'e been saying it for years. A poor mans Ollie Wines!

OMAC Surely, with his athleticism, skill and pace MUST play on the wing!! ?

OK I reckon this guy like many others is devoid of confidence , and the club has mystifyingly not played him in a team which is crying out for KEY marking forwards because of Goodwins shanbolic, forward structure! ok he kicked 3 GREAT GOALS in a cut throat elimination final, but also did some great work in creating opportunities up the ground!! If i CAN SEE IT and many on demonland can see it WHY the perfuurg cant Goodwin and match brains trust???? To answer the main question... He will move to COLLINGWOOD and become a superstar like Howe and to a lesser extent Dunne TYPICAL MFC INCOMPETENCE in developing players!

AGREE and has been unfairly CRUCIFIED by many here and in the media! I'm backin ya son!

Have you got ur floatation device ready?? Also nar, only the Dees would recruit so poorly in Cale the whale and dare i say it ..... Jimmy Toumpas! only us!!?

I DO 1 The Coach cannot 2 The strategy doesnt work and there is no plan B,C,D 3 We recruit players which have poor skills and play them ( to the detriment of say a HARLEY BENNELL) 4 Coach refuses to play at least 2 if not three talls because ...go back to piont 2 5 I agree with Lyon, Schwarta eta al are spot on 6 Club is tetering and the fact we wont get a 1st round pick was arrogant and negligent bargaining.

Well I'm half cut for a Monday ... And I still feel shizen Gawd Can we get of the Merry go Round?? Gee a zillion years for NO REWARD Gawd and i empathise with many who are strugglin! I think iLL HAVE ANOTHER!

Greg Parke says HI!! Once held the record for number of marks in a VFL Game One other thing .. I saw Rob Flower playing CHF in a State game,towell up Ross Glendinning playing CHB I think it was 83? Vs W.A I think he kicked 4 or 5 that day! Just digressing, the memories did bring a momentary smile to my dial! Just for an instant!

Bang! so we have little flexible options? And why is that?

Yep and this is the most damning summation at all Goodwin refuses to shake things up and try plan B,C D and why is that??? Coz he is delusionally thinking his gameplan A is PENULTIMATLY good. Well sorry but is aint!

Yes and can you imagine him in a Team, that plays like one and well coached and drilled?

I wonder if he is being Overcoached, too many getting into his ear that he doesn't know whether to Kick, Handball etc. I reckon just say to him do what comes naturally and take game on.TOO GOOD A PLAYER NOT TO BOUNCE BACK!

I like it a lot Inns Weeds, Brown, Bennell ( Consider Jones, Jetta Outs Melksham, Tomlinson, Hunt, Vanders Viney I'll work a side outa that latter but agree a few things MUST CHANGE eg HARLEY BENNELL Must play forward commision T Mac to CHB Weeds key deep Forward Brown, insurance for above Smith CHF Harmes in midfield Fritta HFF